Year of the Dog, Age of the Kid

Browse News

In the U.S., over 4 million dogs are euthanized each year. But some rescues won't let their small dogs be adopted by families with children.

We first heard of this story in the Ellen Degeneres case – when the Mutts and Moms rescue took a dog from a family with 11 and 12 year old girls.

Mutts and Moms, as well as many other groups, say they have the animals' best interest in mind by imposing these restrictions.

But for some families, a small dog is the best choice. And considering the 4 million euthanized dogs – there's room for debate on the issue.

We found rescues with age limits varying from 7 to 14 years-old. But one group in Long Island New York that doesn't impose age limits says that it really depends on the child.

According toPetOrphans.com – a rescue that doesn't place dogs weighing less that 15 pounds with children – kids pose too great a risk to tiny dogs.

They say small dogs are frequently surrendered after biting a child – but often kids will over-stimulate them first, causing the bite. Kids are also prone to dropping things, an obvious risk to small breeds.

In the end, it's up to the rescue to decide. But we want to know what you think. Should kids be allowed to have small dogs?

Tell us what you think below this story. Post your pet videos at the zootooTV tab. You can email us at news@zootoo.com or email us at 877-777-4204.

Bookmark & Share: Newsvine Newsvine  Digg Digg  Del.icio.us Del.icio.us  Reddit Reddit


Tags


How do you like this article?

91%, 42 out of 46 users thumbed up.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down

Discuss this topic

Comments



342 comments found.
Show: 50 100 200 Per Page
 
Natalie
Natalie (Doulton)
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
If they have had a bunch of cases and a lot of evidence, then they should probably set up a family screening process.
 
Sue R.
Sue R. (suerob)
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I see no difference with large dogs and small dogs when it comes to the children. Supervision and training are the key.
 
suezie
suezie
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
My thoughts. I've seen children (and adults) bitten by both small and large dogs. Supervise!
 
Brigit800
Brigit800
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
And large dogs that are easy going get hurt probably more easily than little dogs that are grumpy.
 
Some children have not been taught by their parents on how to treat an animal-shame on parents.
 
Mary P.
Mary P. (marysworld)
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
should be a case by case analysis. Some kids are more mature than others & more responsible as well.
 
Doggieluvs
Doggieluvs
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Yes, correct and some dogs adjust to little ones better as well.
 
It depends on the situation. Some children are ok with smaller dogs, but then there are some children who would pull the dogs ear, and tail--making the dog angry.
 
capt1928
capt1928
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think it is a parents responsibility to teach their children how to properly take care of a pet large and small. Step up to the plates parents.
 
Linda W.
Linda W. (equs2)
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
The very small dog is fragile and kids are hard on dogs. I like to see a dog about the size of a beagle with kids. Still smallish but big enough to take a bit of rough housing. The little, little dog is not the one being put down in the shelters unless it fails temparament tests or is in a shleter that just isn't doing their job as far as adoptions go. I have done adoptions in two different shelters in my area and I could adopt out more very small dogs.
 
Hannanahmom
Hannanahmom
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree with Teresa K. A blanket policy with no exceptions does not help anybody, especially all these animals who need good homes.
 
Teresa K.
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think each family and each dog should be screened individually and not a blanket rule given.
 
JAG
JAG
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I also think you have to take it by the case and not just a blanket decision.
 
Connie G.
Connie G. (cgleason)
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I don't agree with Gene that Most kids are out of control. I do agree some are and it should be looked at on a case by case basis. But if it's adoption with a younger child or being put down...Unfortunately the Paris Hiltons of the world are making the pocketbook pets popular. It's rediculous.
 
Natalie
Natalie (Doulton)
5 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree. Each family needs to be looked at individually. The fact is that a child's behavior is often determined by the responsiblity quotient of the parents.
 
Gene M.
Gene M. (lablover60)
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I Rescue, and it seems small kids and dogs do not go together. The main problem is, most kids are out of control. They are loud and do not respect their parents. They treat the dog bad, and then it is returned if you are lucky. If not it is tortured and then bites, and its the dogs fault.

No I keep my fosters, until a responsible owner comes along. Kids crying wanting my dogs doesn't phase me, they need to learn they can't have everything they want.
 
the kids need to learn early no matter what that dogs have feeling and they should not do anything to hurt them. parents need to be responsible!!!
 
Paula S.
Paula S. (diogee8)
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Some people would say that they never hear of a small dog biting a child, but rather it always seems to be a larger dog. The main reason for this is that the larger dog causes more damage than a smaller one. If I had to do a count on the number of bite reports I receive annually at my shelter most of them involving a child are often done by small breed dogs. Typically the chihuahua, yorkie, Lhasa apso, and cocker spanial are the breeds most frequently reported.
 
Paula S.
Paula S. (diogee8)
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think this depends on two factors. One the way the kids behave around all animals and how they behave in general. Two how well the dog is with situations they can encounter living with small children.
 
marlyn p.
marlyn p. (skyyma2)
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
OH and if you are going to get a dog, get a sturdy one that will stand up the the little ones. Teach the kiddo not to pull the tail, sit on the pup, poke him in the eye.
 
marlyn p.
marlyn p. (skyyma2)
6 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Why is this an issue? Responsible parents and responsible pet owners. Period.
 
Shirley B.
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I believe in age limits on children. NO PARENT can watch a child and dog every waking minute. It is better to err on the side of safety. Little children do not understand the danger. Until the day dogs can talk, it is our responsibility to keep dogs and children safe. Both dogs and children can be very unpredictable.
 
maria s.
maria s. (yasou8)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
yes kids should be allowd. i hear more stories about the big dogs bititng children. its the parents choice. if theyh adopt a dog when they have a child then they should keep full eye on the child, and make sure nothing happens.
 
Louise P.
Louise P. (lmpickford)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I don't think shelters should have a set rule about not placing small dogs in homes with small children. I think it is up to the shelter to find a good fit for the dogs and up to the parents to let the shelter know the family situation. Some small dogs like children and visa versa. Its also up to the parents to teach the children how to treat animals.
 
Jenn
Jenn (Jenn7703)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It depends on the child and the parents to be responsible.
 
Tami T.
Tami T. (Tatesq)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I do think some dogs are at risk when placed with kids.
 
Betty B.
Betty B. (bblakley07)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It depends on how the parents have raised their child. I do believe that a very small dog is in jeopardy of being hurt by a toddler not intentionally but just because toddlers are all over the place. I can understand why rescue groups would not want to adopt out small breeds to a family with a small child or children. I also know that kids from 4 & up can be very responsible with animals. It's much easier if the child grows up with animals and is taught how to treat them from a young age. I would not eant to adopt out a small breed to a family of a child under the age 4 or 5 that has never had a dog or any pets.
 
LadySephiroth
LadySephiroth
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It depends on the child and should be handled on a case-by-case basis.
 
Felicia
Felicia (felicia606)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
it should be case by case
 
John K.
John K. (hugebear)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
i agree... it should be on individual basis and at the shelters discretion
 
Michael
Michael (Panther1)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
i think it needs to be done on an indivdual basis...some kids are much more mature than others...though the shelter should still have the final say
 
charmedone92
charmedone92
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I disagree and think that it depends on the maturity and needs of the child.
 
Lara W.
Lara W. (dobby4me)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
As long as parents communicate how careful children need to be with smaller animals, I don't think it's a problem....unfortunately a lot of people don't have parenting skills like they should.
 
christina m.
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I don't think it's the size of the dog so much as the maturity of the kid. Any pet needs supervision around children.
 
GRAM B.
GRAM B. (paweba)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Doesn't matter age, size, dogs and children need to be evaluated and monitored. Education is dwefinately neded for the children and the animals....
 
Lindsey
Lindsey (mamasky)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree with some age restrictions but I think it should be on a case to case basis.
 
Jessie
Jessie (Iamjesslarue)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
well, i agree with age restrictions. Though every situation is different. Check vet references.
 
beaglemutz
beaglemutz
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Any situation should be considered on its own merit. Dogs and kids go together. I would not overgeneralize.
 
dana R.
dana R. (DanaJ824)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Each situation does need to be evaluated on a case by cases basis. However most educated parents know that tiny dogs are not ideal for situations involving family with small kids.
 
Lisa
Lisa (Puparazzi)
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think each situation has to be evaluated individually. At first glance, it would seem that an 11 and 12 year old are old enough for a small dog. They do have special needs because of their size - they are easily injured.
 
janicevarley
janicevarley
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
This should definitely depend on the home. It's like putting out breed restrictions. Don't discriminate against ALL pit bulls because one attacks. And don't discriminate against ALL children because one is careless. Isn't that why you are required to get acquainted with a pet prior to adoption? Maybe there just needs to be more supervision by the shelter when families and potential pets interact. Also, it's not really the children's fault...like an owner can raise a dog to be an attacker, a parent can raise a child to be responsible. There are too many pets in shelters to impose restrictions like this.
 
JudyNBob
JudyNBob
7 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
There are some dogs that should not be places in families with small children but each case should be evaluated seperately as to the dog and the child and the parents.
 
betty p.
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Usually our shelter does not get in too many small dogs. However on the kittens, we do have a policy. Kids under 5 years, no kitten under 5 months. Here is why. One year several small kittens were being returned at different times, months, etc. all injured or dead. All had been squeezed, stepped on, dropped and all had kids in the family under 5 years. So we made the policy.

Now we can also tell you we will consider some families with kids under 5 years for kittens under 5 months. But it is a case by case thing. And yes, we have denied folks for the smaller kittens.

So yes, I can see this for the smaller dogs but I think most kids over the age of 8 can understand what they can and can not do with the dogs. Just my opinion.
 
George P.
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I have to agree with Betty P. on this. I was at PetSmart the other day and this little girl maybe 5 years old was walking around carrying this little puppy. I found out the puppy was only 6 weeks old (too young to be away from its mom), it was a chihuahua. While talking to them, the puppy got jumpy and the little girl squeezed the puppy and the puppy cried out. Mom took the puppy from the little girl and told her not to do that again. That she had already told her too many times that she should remember it.

Needs to be an age limit, but I think 7 to 14 year old kids might be okay. But then again, wasn't it a 15 year old who put the hampster in the dryer.
 
Jessica R.
Jessica R. (jdraygor)
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think it should be case by case
 
Getta S.
Getta S. (gettadog)
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
This can be a tough call.I think it depends on the child and the parent/s.I believe if a child walks in to the shelter totally out of control and misbehaved then "NO!" if the parents cannot control that child in public then what is that child like at home ? A child comes in and is good,well behaved and the parent is at that child's side explaining how to pet a dog,telling the child to ask permission to pet an animal,etc.,then I say yes.
 
Margene  W.
Margene W. (mwhitt)
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think it has to be done on a case by case basis-just depending on the dog and children.I think alot of adoption shelters,in their efforts to protect the animals misses out on a lot of really good adoptions.Just make them have a waiting period so it won't be an impluse adoption.
 
Ed D.
Ed D. (MrEd)
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Yeah, it depends so much on the dog and the kids. Children aren't born knowing how to handle animals, and dogs see children as different from adults - in the way they move, the sounds they make, everything. Some dogs freak out at this, some just love the kids up.
 
LettyGalbraith
LettyGalbraith
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
each dog and each family need to be evaluated separetly. You should not just make a blanket restriction like this one. Some children are great with animals and some dogs are great with children!
 
Baileejean
Baileejean
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think it depends on the child and the dog. Making arbitrary rules will deny some dogs great homes. Each situation should be evaluated independently.
 
Beaglepawz
Beaglepawz
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Kids and dogs go together. The important thing is to match the family with the dog as best a spossible and provide lots of tech support and follow up.
 
WELL IF A FAMILY WANTS A SMALL DOG THEY WILL PROBABLY GET ONE REGARDLESS IF IT IS AT A SHELTER OR SOMEWHERE ELSE...SO POSSIBLY SUGGESTING OR EDUCATING THEM WOULD BE A BETTER OPTION. THE PARENTS ARE ULTIMATELY RESPONSIBLE FOR TEACHING THEIR CHILDREN HOW TO TREAT ANY NEW PET. (KIDS HAVE HAMPSTERS...SO I DONT GET THE RATIONAL HERE)
 
Kay Kay
Kay Kay (kayemmkay)
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Okay I could understand this b/c I heard of young children accidentally choking guinea pigs by over loving them. I see how the same thing could happen w/ a small dog. But I think that humane societies should do an evalulation of the parents. Then let the parents decide. Besides, what if a couple has a chihuahua then they have a kid. What now? Also I think it really depends on the child. If the kid's a wild child, umm maybe not but if their sweet & sensitive (unlike me) I think they should give it a chance.
 
PrincessDaisy
PrincessDaisy
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
ever since my 6 month old daughter was born I let her "pet" our dogs. WHen she would grab their fur i would tell her no and flatten her hand and make her gently pet them. SHe's 6 months now and she occassionally grabs them but I'm always close by to catch her and correct her. Parents should never leave an animal and a child alone in the same room. we just have to educate the children about how to handle a pet. I guess sometimes you have to educate the adult/owner of the pets too. Pets shouldn't be restricted from finding their permanent home just because it has a small child. Who knows maybe the kid and the dog will get along just fine, and maybe it will take some time & training to get used to eachother.
 
PackLeader1
PackLeader1
8 months ago
Flag this comment | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Its not the size of the dog that matters, it the stability of the dogs mind.

Latest Comments

News Archive

Seven Tigers Survive Gas Station’s Gimmick

KEENESBURG, Colo. -- Ever since ther...

'Smart Cat' Survives 75-Mile Trek on Spare Tire

GILBERT, Ariz. -- There is nothing u...

Elephant Aces Math Test, Amazes Experts

TOKYO -– Part of a species long be...

‘School’ Teaches Fish to Play Soccer, Basketball

LOS ANGELES -- There’s a new schoo...