zootoo.com Bringing pet lovers together to help pets and each other

Petal Leaves Legacy of Longevity in Philly

Browse News

PHILADELPHIA -- Petal, a 52-year-old African elephant died, at the Philadelphia Zoo on June 9. She was the oldest elephant living in a U.S. Zoo.

Zoo officials who found her sleeping on her side at 7 a.m. immediately knew something was amiss, since she normally sleeps standing up. Despite attempts made by vets and zoo staff who rushed to Petal’s aid, she passed away two hours later.

“This is a great loss to the Philadelphia Zoo family and the greater Philadelphia community,” Zoo CEO, Vikram H. Dewan, told Pet Pulse.

Petal, who was born in Tanzania, had lived at the Philadelphia Zoo for 51 years. Statistically, Petal lived a long-life. According to Debbie Olson director of Conservation and Science Programs for the Indianapolis Zoo and African elephant studbook keeper for the Association of Zoos and Aquariums, the average life expectancy for a female African Elephant is 41 years.

One of three African elephant residents at the Philadelphia Zoo, Petal was the dominant member of the herd and has been described by those who knew her as being dignified and even-tempered, and as a “charismatic icon.”

“Petal will be warmly remembered by staff and generations of visitors as one of our most beloved animals,” Dewan said. “She was a great ambassador for the endangered and threatened wild elephants of Africa and Asia. She will be missed.”

Although Petal had no biological offspring, fellow herd members Kallie and Bette -- who were half her age -- will need to adjust to life without their surrogate mother.

“We don’t know exactly what Kallie and Bette are feeling at this point,” said Dr. Andrew Baker, vice president for Animal Programs at Philadelphia Zoo. “It is definitely a change. We decided that it was important to give them the opportunity to say good-bye and be with her after she died.”

So far Kallie and Bette seem calm, according to Baker. Zoo staff will be monitoring them closely to ensure they are handling the transition as well as can be expected.

At 9 feet tall and 12 feet long, Petal weighed almost 9,500 pounds. Due to the elephants’ massive volume, it was planned for them to be moved from the quarter-acre-facility at the Philadelphia Zoo to the 724-acre International Conservation Center in Fairhope at the end of the summer season.

“We had been working towards building a new elephant habitat at the south end of the zoo for a number of years,” Baker said. “Two years ago we reached the conclusion that we were not going to find the funding in a reasonable timeframe. That’s what made us decide to move the elephants to areas that had current resources to put towards their care.”

Although some local animal rights activists are pointing to the elephants’ comparatively small current environment as a contributing factor in Petal’s death, Olson maintains that the size of the Elephant’s habitat at the zoo is not a concern.

“Space is not the issue. It is the whole management and care program for the elephants,” Olsen said. “You could give any animal unlimited space, but they are only going to use the space that they need to find food, water and have mates.”

Petal’s cause of death is currently unknown, but a forth coming necropsy will be performed.

“It is too early to know exactly what happened,” Dr. Baker said. “Petal had been in excellent health through her years at the Zoo, showing no recent signs of illness or decline. We will know much more in the days ahead.”

There are 155 African elephants in AZA accredited Zoological Institutions throughout the U.S. and Canada -- and of them one now moves up to take Petal’s place as the oldest.

“Now that we’ve lost Petal, I believe the new oldest African elephant is a female named Hydari at the Hogle Zoo in Utah. She is 48.” Olsen said.

Tell us what you think about “Petal Leaves Legacy of Longevity in Philly” below. Share your favorite videos by clicking on the ZootooTV tab. Send us your story ideas by e-mailing us at news@zootoo.com or by calling us at 877-777-4204.



Tags


How do you like this article?

80%, 4 out of 5 users thumbed up.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down

Discuss this topic

Comments



106 comments found.
Show: 50 100 200 Per Page
 
Kimberly F.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Goodbye, Petal.
 
beverlyyerk
beverlyyerk
2 weeks ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
how sad
 
Chris
Chris (animaldaddy)
4 weeks ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
How sad.
 
daryl b.
daryl b. (darylob)
1 month ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
me again don't forget that the philly zoo is the oldest in the country and has made some very special changes over the years. when i was a little kid sooooo many years ago they had monky island it was great they were not in cages but an island type thing and i haven't seen it but hear they redid it and i bet it is even more special
 
daryl b.
daryl b. (darylob)
1 month ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
this one was particularly sad for me as a child i used to see petal when my parents took me to the zoo. i am sure she is in eley heaven now playing like she was young again and seeing old friend that she has never forgotten
 
Vicki T.
Vicki T. (LuvYourPets)
2 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think it sounds like the Philadelphia Zoo is doing the right thing by moving the elephants at the end of the season to the 724-acre Conservation Center in Fairhope. It's too bad they couldn't get the funding to increase their elephant's habitat themselves. I have a hard time seeing animals in zoos and refuse to support circuses who use animals, but Petal Did live to be 52 years old and if the average life span of an elephant is only 41, then it sounds like she may have had a good life. I'm sure her keepers are grieving over her loss. Rest in peace, Petal. You were a good matriarch and I hope the other elephants can adjust to her loss. This is a very sad story, but I'm glad they're all going to that large preserve soon.
 
Carol L.
Carol L. (langsford)
1 month ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I agree, this must mean she was well taken care of. I am sorry to hear about her passing but happy the zoo appears to really care about the other two who felt this was their mother. Elephants bond for life so it is very hard for them when a member dies..
 
If the average lifespan is 41 years, and Pedal was 52, I have to say the zoo must have been doing something right. I agree though that elephants are nomadic by nature and should have a large pet to free-roam in. I'm glad the remaining elephants will be transferred to a larger home soon.
 
Carly T.
Carly T. (Carly67)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
how sad.
 
ruthie
ruthie (ruthiegirl66)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
What is truely amazing about zootoo is it gives all of us a place to come together and discuss our thoughts and beliefs on animals and the world. I almost learn more from the conversations started by news articles than from the article itself.
I don't know anything about this particular zoo but i do know it would be so much better if these larger animals had appropriate habitats not just an enclosure. i would hope this and other zoos will learn to make the best possible situation for these animals to live in, especially if they are going to have a long life span. It wouldn't be great to be chained in a small area only to be let out for a little while each day. Hopefully they can do better by the other elephants and so to other zoos.
 
sebby2008
sebby2008
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
And here is the link for the PAWS sanctuary on the west coast.

http://www.pawsweb.org

They have, as the Tennessee sanctuary has, a live cam for viewers to be able to see the elephants in the closest thing to a natural habitat for captive elephants who have been freed from their prisonlike life in a zoo or circus. If you navigate over the website you will also see that they have video updates of their elephants. The latest is of Ruby's 1st year anniversary celebrated in April.

PAWS recently acquired Maggie, a lone African elephant from of all places, the Alaska Zoo .... PAWS now has five African elephants that are thriving in the California climate roaming on many acres as they were meant to. Maggie will celebrate her 1-year anniversary on November 2, 2008.
 
princesmom
princesmom
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
To all here who think Petal had a decent life, I would like to add the following.
Years ago, the elephant house at the Philly Zoo allowed visitors to watch the elephants being brought in at night.....into the same cage now that was there 50 years ago........a cage of bars with cement floor and accessible for viewing by the public standing in a wide hallway. In that cement there are some sort of hooks to fasten each elephant by a leg. Piles of hay are stationed in front of each hook for their evening meal. Nighttime consists of many hours that those elephants are chained and can hardly move with their TREMENDOUS weight bearing down on the pads of their feet connecting with unyielding concrete, feet which were only designed to walk on land and grasses. Ask yourself whether you think this kind of stationary position is comfortable for an elephant half or more of every single day of its life.
Also ask yourself, if this is suitable to do to this animal, why then has the zoo blocked off that hall so no visitors can watch......or maybe I should say.....complain?
Even unknowledgeable people "know" when they are seeing something that is totally wrong.
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
Papa5
Papa5
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Michele, I can asssure you elephants are migratory by nature. At The Elephant Sanctuary, they are given plenty of food and water, yet they roam the entire 2700 acre expanse of their habitat. Elephants need the exercise to maintain healthy feet, joints, muscle tone, digestive system and circulation. Standing around on hard surfaces, as they must in zoos like Philly's, wreaks havoc on them physically. The fact that petal lasted to the age of 52 is practically a miracle, given her living conditions. In the wild, she probably could have lived well into her 70's or 80's.
 
syntexerror101
syntexerror101
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
as i was reading the article i was thinking exactly what you said here. her life wasn't that long for an elephant, but rather just long for an elephant that lives in a zoo. when living in a zoo cuts an animal's life expectancy in half, maybe we should take a long, hard look at why it is living there in the first place.
 
sebby2008
sebby2008
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Carryl - Let me try to spell it out for you and anyone else that does not see the forest for the trees here -- if you have ever visited the Philadelphia Zoo elephant exhibit you would see for yourself that Petal and her companions enclosure was much too small for an animal of that size -- it would be like having three (formerly four - Dulary the Asian elephant was sent to a Tennessee sanctuary in May 2007 - she was the lucky one) overweight people living in a studio apartment for 50 years -- and besides, in a 24-hour period these elephants spent more time chained inside the barn than outside in the habitat. How natural is that? -- their life at the zoo was the furthest thing from a natural life. As zoo elephants (and circus elephants) cannot be returned to the wild, a sanctuary is the closest thing to a natural life for these poor animals who did not choose a zoo or circus life - they were forced. Retire them now so they may have a second chance to be an elephant again and not just and exhibit to entertain humans - there are plenty of other forms of entertainment.
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
Carryl D.
Carryl D. (carryld)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I'm not really sure what to make of this story. She was the oldest elephant living in US zoo history, yet her enclosure is being blamed for her demise???
 
Papa5
Papa5
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Betty, elephants need a lot of space (they are migratory by nature) and freedom of choice, and varying substrates with naturally growing vegetation to browse on. Small zoo exhibits in the middle of a big city are not where elephants belong. We have to get over these old zoo and circus myths that these industries have fed to the public for years. Keeping elephants in zoos has nothing to do with wild elephant conservation and the way they are kept is cutting their lives desperately short by depriving them of the conditions they need to thrive. Keeping them in zoos has been compared to locking a person in a small closet for decades. I think we need a lot more empathy for these creatures.
 
Michele
Michele (MicheleZ)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I can see the point that elephants weren't meant to live in zoos or other confined spaces, but I think some of the expressions used as evidence that elephants don't belong in zoos are exaggerated to elicit pity. For example, you stated that "keeping them [elephants] in zoos has been compared to locking a person in a small closet for decades", but I don't believe that zoo elephants are completely shut off from sunlight and kept in total (or near total) darkness for decades. They have somewhat more room and ARE allowed outdoors. Secondly, you pointed out that "elephants need a lot of space (they are migratory by nature)", but aren't they more "migratory by necessity" (i.e., the need to move to another location in order to find a sufficient supply of food and/or water)? This may never happen, but IF elephants were given a sanctuary without fencing to contain them and provided with sufficient amounts of daily food and water, would those elephants migrate? I think they would stay close to the readily available food/water source. (As the population increased, they might have to expand outward, but I'm questioning if elephants are "migratory by nature" or "migratory by necessity".)
 
syntexerror101
syntexerror101
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
i don't know if it's so much migratory by nature but rather they just need so much space to roam that a zoo could never properly house them. they are quite large animals and they cover a lot more space in one day than you would think. i would also imagine that not having enough space available to them stresses them out, which is part of the reason why they have such drastically shorter lives in zoos.

there's no arguing with numbers though, if an elephant that lives her life in a zoo is only expected to live 41 years, when if that same elephant were living in the wild she would be expected to live to be 70 or 80, then it is clear something is going on and it must not be healthy to keep these animals in a zoo setting.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I agree with Michele on the migratory by necessity. If elephants would have everything they needed in one location, why move. I believe it is because food source runs low, so they move on.

And as for Zoos, I guess I am spoiled as the Columbus Ohio Zoo is one of the best ones around. Jack Hanna has done a wonderful job of making sure all the animals have what they need to be healthy and happy.
 
princesmom
princesmom
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Betty, if you didn't have to move or drive to work to earn the money to go somewhere and purchase your food, possibly bring it home and cook it, then eat it, but instead could sit and have something brought to you whenver you wanted to eat, to stay alive, ....what condition would your body be in? This is no exaggeration. An elephant's HUGE body requires its wild lifestyle to stay active, fit, and not become sickly and obese. This is only one of the major reasons why it is cruel to keep an elephant in a zoo.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Well, after reading the story and comments below, I am wondering where some folks (Rowen) are getting all their facts on Petal. Do you work at the Zoo or have a friend who does. Or what.

As for Zoos, I believe that sometimes they take in a young one when it has nobody left which could be how Petal ended up at a zoo. If something happened to her herd, why leave her in the wild with no protection. The Zoo would be a better chance.

I know that some zoos are better than other at working on rehabing animals to get them back into the wild if possible. They work on breeding programs to help if endangered. There is some good that comes from Zoos. And I for one will always be a member of our Columbus Zoo.
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Aww rest in peace Petal. Best wishes to the remaining 2 elephants that are surely missing Petal. They all seem to be well taken care of & Petal will be missed by humans & animals alike.
 
Papa5
Papa5
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Petal spent over 50 years in a substandard, deprived zoo exhibit at Philly. In the wild, unhindered by humans, she could have lived over 70 years. When we attend a zoo, we should realize that the animals held there are being forced to live in a way that is completely unnatural for them. This is inhumane. We did not understand this in the 19th century when zoos were started. But we don't have that excuse today. Petal's tragic death should underscore for the zoo that it is time to get their two surviving elephants to a sanctuary. Petal would want to see her friends, Kallie and Bette, live a better life than she was allowed. Let's stop being ignorant and clueless and act as though we can learn and accept the truth and do the compassionate thing for these largest land mammals on earth.
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
Are you a PETA member?
 
acedogg2001
acedogg2001
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I hope Petal had a good life and now is resting in peace.
 
wendy w.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Peace be with you Petal.......
 
Rachel  E.
Rachel E. (Ladybug8)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 4 users liked it.
Reply
Rowan, don't get me wrong, I completely respect your opinion and I'm glad that you are so passionate about animals, but why are you CONFRONTING me about it? If you feel so passionate about it, create a petition or something of that nature. I realize that you feel very strongly about this, but I'm not the one to be talking to about this issue.......
 
LINDA421419 B.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Now the elephant is in the land of the free.
 
Rachel  E.
Rachel E. (Ladybug8)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
Rowan, how about we agree to disagree and drop it. Not everyone shares the same opinion, which is a good thing, otherwise the world would be a boring place. We each have a mind and an opinion of our own, your spoken yours and now I'm speaking mine.
 
RowanMorrison
RowanMorrison
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It's not a matter of a different opinion, but rather that people aren't getting the facts. And I can't "drop it" as long as there are two beautiful elephants suffering in the same horrendous conditions that Petal was forced to live in for over 50 years. There's a chance for Kallie and Bette to live somewhat of a life, but the zoo refuses to give them that chance. :(
 
Michele
Michele (MicheleZ)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
You seem to be misdirecting your energy.
 
Bob C.
Bob C. (rjcronk)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
alot of interesting debate on whether she lived a long life or not. ... and if she was happy.. If she was chained as much as one commentor says I cannot imagine her life was very happy... 51 years of being chained up every day... how happy would you be. Maybe we ought to chain up the zoo director for a week and see how he enjoys it.
 
RowanMorrison
RowanMorrison
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Ask the zoo how much she was chained. It's the one thing they can't deny.
 
Janet V.
Janet V. (janeyv)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
This elephant lived a long life and it was just her time to go. Bless her elephant heart!
 
princesmom
princesmom
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
This elephant did not live a long life....70-80 would have been a long life. She probably either had something wrong with her with no visible symptoms, or she just 'gave up' out of sheer lack of will to stay alive. It was pathetic to see how unhappy she was, in person. If you observe enough elephants in person, on film, and in photos, their behavior and expressions and general mood become somewhat apparent to any person who is familiar with expressions, mood, and behavior of their own pets.
 
jerZgirl
jerZgirl
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
Don't the PETA people have anything else to do but piss and moan about this? The animal was loved and well cared for. The fact that she is missed by her keepers and the public must mean something.

A good zoo is the best place for children to learn and respect wildlife, I love zoos and will always go to them. Same with aquariums.

Please DO SHUT UP-fil your mouth with salad or something.
 
RowanMorrison
RowanMorrison
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I love animals, not zoos. I think about the lives of the animals, not how much I like seeing them. I understand not everyone has the same compassion for animals, unfortunately.
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
Rachel  E.
Rachel E. (Ladybug8)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 3 users liked it.
Reply
Rowan, Elephants are used to that kind of heat...Africa is one the hottest continents on the face of this planet, they're adapted to that particular climate. I'm saying if the space and the 'heat' were the COD it would've happened a long time ago, like day 1. Appearantly it didn't have that negative of an effect on her, she lived BEYOND expectation. Nonetheless, time and the necropsy will tell.
 
RowanMorrison
RowanMorrison
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
She lived "beyond expectation" only because zoo elephants die prematurely. Stop taking zoo rhetoric as fact and learn the truth.
 
Michele
Michele (MicheleZ)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
If there were accurate statistics regarding the number of African elephants in the wild and African elephants held "captive" in zoos, and we knew the age at which each elephant actually succumbed (for whatever reason), I'd be willing to bet that disproportionately MORE ZOO female African elephants live to the "average life expectancy age of 41 years" than do "wild female African" elephants. (And there would be a similar finding for male zoo vs. wild elephants, based on their average life expectancy.)
 
RowanMorrison
RowanMorrison
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
If you really want to learn about a "long-lived" elephant, check out the Amboseli project and learn about Echo...the matriarch who is still going strong in her 60's!!!
http://www.elephanttrust.org
 
daryl b.
daryl b. (darylob)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
being raised in philly i had seen petal many times. now my heart is sad for the people who will never get to see her. but not for her. now she is free. the philly zoo as the oldest zoo in the country always was a wonderful lace to go. there old monkey island was just terrific. i understand they have redone it. if people had been more generous with their donations they would have been able to build there elehant habitat so petal could have had more freedom. so please peole give a little to the rescues, zoo's, shelter and anyother place that tries to make animals lives better even though they are not free BLESS YOU PETAL and all who loved her
 
sebby2008
sebby2008
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
The Philadelphia Zoo did the right thing for Dulary, their only Asian elephant, but did not come through for Petal. At 52 years of age, she should have been retired to a sanctuary where she could live out her remaining years on acres of land in the company of other elephants. Instead, the zoo chose to keep her in the studio apartment-like enclosure that she lived for 50 years. How thoughtful is that? These elephants spent more hours of the day chained inside the barn than in the outside enclosure. The barn was their prison cell and the outside enclosure was their prison yard. In the wild, elephants are not confined to a small area. They need and have space to roam and forage. These poor elephants lives were stolen from them all for the sake of human entertainment. The human race should hang their heads in shame!!
 
ourstaff
ourstaff
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
A part of Petal will live on in the memories of the public and the younger elephants that grew up under her guidance
 
Nancy W.
Nancy W. (kc2la)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It's always sad to hear of an animal passing away. It does sound like she was healthy and received good care so hopefully she just passed from old age and not some undiagnosed disease that caused her any discomfort or pain. I hope that the other two herd members continue to cope well with losing her.
 
rakubu
rakubu
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Zoos aren't the same as the wild, we all know that. For some animals, they are a good alternative, though depending upon why they're there. In this case, at least, it seems Petal was much loved. I'm sure you broke some hearts when she left, but she'll be remembered.
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
RowanMorrison
RowanMorrison
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
No. An elephant's average lifespan is 70. The life expectancy in the wild is artificially low because elephants are subject to poaching and culling. The fact that Petal was the oldest elephant in a U.S. zoo is a cause for alarm, not something to brag about.
 
Michele
Michele (MicheleZ)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 3 users liked it.
Reply
I've never heard of using "average" lifespan. The lifespan for the African Elephant is estimated to be 60-70 years. But an "average life expectancy" is a totally different term. I don't know much at all about elephants, but applying the terms to humans, it can be said that the human lifespan (oldest "confirmed" age) is about 122 years--and some believe it may be "limitless". I think we all know that relatively few humans live to 122 years of age. The "average life expectancy" will vary with geographic location, lifestyle, sex, etc., but is about 77 years in the U.S. It would be absurd to state something like: if we'd release U.S. prisoners serving life sentences they'd have a lifespan of 122 years instead of their average life expectancy of 73.6 for men and 79.4 for women.

Maybe the elephant would have lived longer....and maybe it would have died younger in a different environment. Maybe, maybe, maybe....
 
Jessica S.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Rest in peace Petal, you were loved by many!
 
Liz
Liz (PurrPurrsMom)
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
I believe we should use zoos as teaching tools as well as for our enjoyment. Teach our children respect for wild animals and how we should care for them. They were after all building a new elephant area before Petal died. Some people don't take care of their own pets as well.
 
princesmom