zootoo.com Bringing pet lovers together to help pets and each other

No Kill Advocate’s Goal: Create an Army of Compassion

Browse News

SAN CLEMENTE, Calif. -- The term No Kill is common to animal shelter workers and animal advocates nationwide. A No kill shelter is one in which euthanasia is reserved only for the untreatable and untamable animals. Few shelters can claim the title, but author and animal advocate Nathan Winograd believes the country will embrace this methodology within the next decade.

Winograd’s goal: to essentially “create an army of compassion” to change sheltering as Americans know it.

He is the general of this army and his strategy is clearly detailed in his wildly popular new book “Redemption: The Myth of Pet Overpopulation and the No Kill Revolution in America.”

The first-time author published the book in September 2007 and already “Redemption” is in its third printing.

It chronicles Winograd’s career as a No Kill advocate and shows how anyone can transform their shelter, their community into a No Kill facility.

“It’s really a grassroots movement of pet-loving citizens around the country demanding cities to embrace new models of sheltering,” said Winograd, a pet owner who rescued his own companions from shelters.

He has blamed the shelter system for unnecessarily killing healthy, adoptable animals for reasons such as space restrictions.

The notion of “pet overpopulation” in Winograd’s mind is a “myth.” He refers to his research which shows more people are looking to bring dogs and cats into their homes than the number of those put into shelters.

“Right now, in our country, shelters are failing 50 percent of times for dogs in some communities as high as 80 percent for cats,” said Winograd. “The reason is they’re blaming the community for having to kill, but not changing their own behavior that would impact killing.”

Winograd advocates that mobile adoption sites, low cost or free spay and neuter programs and encouraging volunteerism are steps that will combat what he calls “institutional defeatism.”

He helps shelters break through that defeatism by studying their policies and procedures, and recommending changes that will save more animals.

“Not enough shelters are saying ‘what’s wrong?’ Anything we can do to overcome what you see is behavior problem in animals, or inability to afford medical care for animals, or environmental problems like, ‘my landlord doesn’t allow pets,’ ” said Winograd. “If shelters did those things, and did those things comprehensively, and did those things rigorously, we’d be a no kill nation today.”

Through his consultant work, the creation of the No Kill Advocacy Center in Oakland, Calif., and now his book, Winograd continues to preach what he sees as the inevitable reality of a No Kill nation.

“I think we’ll be a no kill nation in five to 10 years, and killing will be seen by the next generation as a cruel aberration of the past,” said Winograd.

Pet Pulse’s coverage of the No Kill Advocate Center and author Nathan Winograd will continue with our series highlighting the No Kill movement.

Tell us what you think about “No Kill Advocate’s Goal: Create an Army of Compassion” below, and be sure to watch the video of this story at the top of your page. Share your favorite videos by clicking on the ZootooTV tab. Send us your story ideas by e-mailing us at news@zootoo.com or by calling us at 877-777-4204.



Tags


How do you like this article?

86%, 13 out of 15 users thumbed up.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down

Discuss this topic

Comments



132 comments found.
Show: 50 100 200 Per Page
 
Sydney  S.
Sydney S. (yukibaby16)
2 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I support any and all strategies to make us a no kill nation! I will definitiely go out and read his book!
 
Claudia
Claudia (HSSAZ)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think that many shelters do what they can. It still comes down to educating the public and getting rid off puppy mills and pet shops.
 
PJ W.
PJ W. (pj0908)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I live in dog country, Texas. I live 2 doors down from a feeder/breeder of cats. My first rescue was a tiny pregnant female. When her litter was born I sent the pics of 4 beautiful kittens to over 100 people. I got 2 responses.
Another person sent a pic of 5 puppies to half of that (50) and they were gone and people wanting more in 10 minutes.
Mr. Winograd needs to come to Texas and show the shelters that overpopulation is a myth. I love his ideas but I have to disagree with him.
Also, spaying and neutering is not affordable here and that is a large part of the problem. I just don't think I understand why it has to remain at over 100.00 when the vets don't keep the animals overnight any more.
A no-kill nation would be wonderful.
 
samsamjr2
samsamjr2
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Every shelter should be a no kill shelter. All animals need loving homes.
 
Tracee G.
Tracee G. (tracee)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Every shelter should be no kill.
 
judy b.
judy b. (jbonz)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Sounds likehe has some good ideas but...I would like to know how he determined that animal overpopulation is a myth. I don't agree with that one. Also, when I take a shelter dog for an outing, I hear from so many people that they'd love to adopt but already have 2,3,8,10 or more pets at home. Where do you find all of these people who want to bring more pets into the home? I encounter more people tryaing to get rid of pets than acquiring them.
 
amy m.
amy m. (houndog990)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Quote from article:
The notion of “pet overpopulation” in Winograd’s mind is a “myth.” He refers to his research which shows more people are looking to bring dogs and cats into their homes than the number of those put into shelters.


I haven’t read the book, but I am on my way to get a copy. I hope he gives directions to the planet he lives on so I can fire up my space ship and bring all the homeless animals from earth to him and all his friends waiting to adopt pets.
 
Desiree A.
Desiree A. (alleycatd)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It would be great if every shelter could be no-kill
 
david n.
david n. (shihtzudad)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
believe it is the responsability of the shelter to enforce spay and nuter policys for the sake of the poor animals my wife and i have recently became involved with our animal shelter in bowling green ky. and their branch off the repet animal aduption center . it is where animals can be seen and worked with and adopted , i only wish more people would get a chance to see these wonderful animals . our county just last week had a meeting to set basic laws for the treatment of animals and a lot of people were mistaken with a law for pet protection and farm animal protection , but all should be protected from crule treatment and given good care for the purpose that they were ment to have food, and shelter, are a basic need . not a tree for shelter as some would think maybe they would like to lie under a tree for shelter i would not .in a pet store in town my wife and i met a man and his family when we had our shih-tzu's with us and all he wanted to talk about was if we could direct him to where he could buy a white one so he could breed it for a lot of money we were apalled and told him we did not we got our babies from a puppy mill which we did not know at the time but are working with the humane society to help get homes for animals not breed more for profit
 
Janie P.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree we need to stop killing animals because of no room in shelters. The public needs to be educated and more low cost spray neuter programs for people that can't afford to pay for it. After all it is not the animals fault, the problem is bad ownership.
 
Jessica H.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
i agree with him that they are blaming the community for having to kill animals when they could put their efforts to try and do other programs to reduce the pet population and get more people to adopt pets
 
dmbutte
dmbutte
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I hope for the animals sake that Winograds predictions come true but with all I know of basset hound rescue there definitely is an over population problem, right now Ohio basset rescue is having to turn away dogs because all the foster homes are full and they are begging for more help and this is just one specific breed.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
That is true about the Ohio Basset Hound rescue. Our shelter had a 5 year old basset hound and asked if rescue could take him. We like pure breeds to go to their rescues so we the shelter and take care of the mutts. The OBH Rescue had no room. So we posted him and got him adopted after a couple weeks, but would have rather he went to them and opened up that cage a bit sooner.
 
Kathleen
Kathleen (mewlkitten)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I think all shelters should be no kill, but unfortunately there are just too many animals to be taken care of, what can we do? we need more help.
 
Carryl D.
Carryl D. (carryld)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I don't competely agree with Winograds thoughts. I do agree with 'No Kill" , however, he states that "overpopulation' is NOT an issue. I beg to differ. But, if he can make a difference...GREAT!!!
 
donteatlipglozz
donteatlipglozz
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
There are plenty of animal rescues, santuarys, and shelter to where they do not need to kill animal for lack of space and/or not being adopted for a certain amount of time. Just because one pet isnt wanted at one shelter, someone in another town/city may want to adopt him. There are plenty of other options than killing and we need to start reseraching them and using them!
 
kelly D.
kelly D. (kelly13603)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
The US army "an army of one"
We need to make this an army of many!
 
Janet V.
Janet V. (janeyv)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I believe all shelters should be a no kill. They are God's creatures and deserve to live. Also there needs to be a better way to adopt these animals. Sometimes I think the restrictions and costs are out of control. What do others think about the adoption rules?
 
Gwen J.
Flag this | Good Point | 12 users liked it.
Reply
Okay, I have a few problems with the author's claims. First: that pet over-population is a myth. Secondly: there are more people looking for pets than are available.

Having worked at an animal shelter that had an animal control cotract, I can tell you that part of the problem is the un-checked breeding practices of a lot of backyard breeders and puppy mills. For this Winograd to make the claim that there are "more people looking to bring dogs and cats into their homes than the number of those put into shelters". Of course this statistic takes into account the many, many people looking for pure-bred or "designer" dogs and cats. I once overheard a breeder make the statement that "there are always homes for the puppies" a few months later she was left with a puppy she had been unable to sell (at $1600.00 each!).

While I do applaud Winograd's attempts to eliminate all un-neccessary euthanasia, I fear that the goal of "5-10 years" may be a little overly optimistic. I do believe that education is a huge part of the equation, but I also believe that there need to be stringent laws regarding the breeding of dogs and cats.
 
Judy S.
Judy S. (JK9CUTS)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I wish people would spay and neuter their pets.
 
Sheryl B.
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
Our shelter was one of the first to establish the no-kill philosophy in the area. I can tell you that the first notions of no-kills were "warehouses" and that is simply not true. No-kills are changing shelter images for the good. They are no longer dark scary places where animals go to die, they are happy places where people can find their new best friend.
There are two things that make for a successful no-kill, in my opinion. One is when there is an evaluation process to evaluate all dogs/cats temperments and then screen adopters as well. This ensures a good fit between new pet and owner and makes for a lifelong love that will be less likely to end up back in a shelter.
The second thing that is a must is an aggressive spay/neuter policy. Not just for the shelter pets but for the community. It has to be simple for the community to use and affordable. This is the true secret to success. It makes the most sense - to get to the root of the problem and stop pets from coming into the shelters in the first place. This book has hit on these points.
It concerns me that there are still a lot of communities that do not have any low cost spay/neuter programs to turn too. At our shelter, we have received countless thank you letters from people using our program and they all say virtually the same thing - thank you for helping me to be responsible. I truly feel that people do want to do the responsible thing and if they have that option at their local shelter they will do it. I agree with this author that we can certainly attain no-kill status in this country if we all join together and get to the root of the problem. If we help people to be responsible owners, then hopefully the next generation will also be responsible and they will only hear about euthanasia in books from the past...
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Can you explain the temperment testing you use on dogs and cats. I have seen some testing and really don't agree with it. So would like to know what you guys do.
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I think this is an exciting prospect to consider. I am going to look for his book. Could you imagine the whole country being no-kill? Awesome isn't a strong enough word to describe it! I really pray this becomes a reality, whether it takes the 5-10 years or more. As long as it happens. What a great guy. I think we should all buy the book & discuss it on Zootoo. Has anyone read it? Where did you buy it?
 
dawn  h.
dawn h. (dawnt)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
We can only hope and pray for a no kill nation to be here in 5-10years. That would be wonderful. I wish it was already in practice everywhere. I wish people would stop buying purebreds from pet stores,puppy mills, and mostly newspaper ads.
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Yup, I agree whole heartedly! Stop buying purebreds & they will have to stop breeding them! It comes down to supply & demand. Simple as that. I hope Martha & Oprah go to shelters for their animals now!
 
frzframe
frzframe
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
There is nothing wrong with getting a pure breed. In fact if responsible owners would spay/neuter their aniamls that would eventually enlimated mutts. If we as a responsible pet owner would only purchase our pure breeds from those who are trying to better their breed that would also help with shutting down puppy mills and back yard breeders. In my shelter in which I am a very active board member the majority of the animals brought in are not pure blood and even whole litters of puppies along with their mom's are brought in. These are the ones we need to target for spaying their animals but sadly a lot of these folks don't care and that it's easier to dump their problems then fix them to begin with.
 
Cassie3
Cassie3
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I could not agree with you more and was glad to hear on Oprah's show that NO ONE had a problem with responsible breeders.
 
kittypassion
kittypassion
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I'll have to get his book. I am in agreement 100% in that we need to be a no-kill nation. It would be great if he could donate a book or contributions could be made to donate a book to every pound in the whole USA. The behavior needs to be changed.
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
You have a great idea. Donate a book to each shelter. Get the word out there to the people that can implement the changes. Teach them how to do it! This is an exctiing subject. I think all animal lovers should read this book & take the information back to their local shelters.
 
Suzanne P.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
You can say that more people want pets than are coming into the shelter - may be true - BUT - BIG BUT HERE - a very large percentage of people focus their attention to purebred dogs - that is the perception that has to change for these animals to find more homes.
 
Fooj
Fooj
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It's a nice goal to have, but probably not that feasible. There are just too many unwanted animals out there, and there really is no space for them. The shelters do their best, but until people change thier ways and spay and neuter their pets, the problem won't go away.
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
This is true that spay/neuter has to be practised by all animal owners. Once all shelters make this a requirement to adopt, we may see some changes start to happen. Once we read this book & get more ideas to implement. Ideas will spread & take hold like little seeds. You have to start somewhere. I agree it's a big job thats being taken on by saying all shelters will be no kill in 5-10 years. Even if it takes 10-15 years isn't that something worth working towards. Wonderful things come from just thinking about it. It won't be over night; but just thinking it could come true in this great country has to give shelter employees & volunteers that deal w/ the pets day in & day out much needed hope!
 
Brenda
Brenda (BrendaM)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It is a great thought. Although there ARE animal population issues - that are of course caused by people... So I do not think that we will be able to become a no-kill nation that quickly. You have to change people's behaviour first - like not breeding, spaying and neutering, and not buying dogs from breeders or pet shops.

The myths he speaks about - like landlords not allowing pets - well - welcome to NYC - it is not myth. My shelter (a no-kill by the way) and a lot of other organziations have dedicated their time to combatting this problem - but guess what - landlords have a lot more pull with politicians usually - so it is truly a struggle for many of not most in NYC.

So what he says is a nice thought - and hopefully we can get there one day - but I think this guy needs to step back into reality first.
 
Cassie3
Cassie3
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
There are realtors who are having better luck with landlords. In order to get space rented/purchased, realtors are convincing landlords to relax their pet clauses. Sign of the times...
 
frzframe
frzframe
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I thought a true "no kill" shelter meant just that...not PTS anything. So, many shelters are understaffed, don't have the space, or the money to keep everything that comes through their doors. They could if they do not accept animals once they have every space full until they are able to adopt some out but that would mean turning away strays. Then what would happen to those animals? Starvation, hit by cars, sickness and a more painful death then in the loving arms of someone who truly care about them.
 
Kelly
Kelly (KellyJedlicki)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
The shelter that I am affiliated with is truly a No-Kill facility. We have some animals that have been with us for 5- 6 years. We are working towards making the county a no-kill county.
 
Amanda R.
Amanda R. (arhoads)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
That's no quality of life for the animal though. 5-6 years in a cage.
 
NewfGirl
NewfGirl
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Better than the alternative, if no appropriate homes can be found! The right shelter can do this successfully by utilizing foster homes, volunteers to walk, train, socialize the animals.
 
Amanda R.
Amanda R. (arhoads)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Would you want to be stuck in a cage listening to other animals bark and cry with nothing to look forward to but occassionally being walked if the shelter can find the volunteers and time. That's cruelty and you wouldn't think it was acceptable if it was an owner doing it.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree with Amanda R. I could not sit in a cage for 5 years getting walked once in a while. Sorry, don't think so. And this is why alot of animals go kennel crazy.
 
Lisa
Lisa (Puparazzi)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I'm not sure about the puppies & kittens under 4 months, but for everything else, the new owner picks up the animal they have adopted from the veterinarian after the surgery.

I am glad that since we got the new director, the SPCA that runs our shelter has done more aggressive marketing of available pets, and increased adoptions. We might qualify as a "no-kill" shelter, but I'm not totally sure. My involvement is more in fund raising and public relations as a volunteer.

I think the "No Kill" philosophy is definitely worth all shelters aspiring to, even if they never totally reach it, as long as they are working toward it, it is tremendous progress in the right direction.

I have talked with the shelter director here about the possibility of doing swaps with other shelters. Labradors are a dime a dozen here, and if it could be arranged, maybe we could swap with a shelter in another area where labs would be more desirable, for something "different" to this area.

Perhaps it could even be a regional network, where if someone was looking for something specific, they could check with other shelters and arrange to have the animal transferred in. If junkyards can do it for car parts, and car dealers for new cars, why not do it for the animals? Obviously there would be many details to work out, but it could be done.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Why not puppies and kittens. Did you know that kittens can get pregnant at 4-5 months old.

For more info on early spay/neuter go here

http://www.columbusdogconnection.com

If we can not get shelters/rescues to do 100%, how can get get the public.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I would like to know how many shelters/rescues do 100% spay/neuter before the animals goes to its forever home. No contracts. We are talking altered before placement.

I ask because there are some no kills that don't do anything under 6 months and to me that is wrong.

I believe no animal should leave a shelter/rescue until it is altered. No excuse.

So again, how many of your shelters do 100% spay/neuter. If you don't, then we can never move to a no-kill or I like better a low kill shelter nation.
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree animals shouldn't leave a shelter until spayed/neutered. It will cost more but its the responsible thing to do for a shelter & country.
 
Fooj
Fooj
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Our Hawaiian Humane Society always spays or neuters all animals before they are released to the new owners. It's $60 to adopt such a pet, which is a real deal!
 
Kate H.
Kate H. (dixiepets)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
I would love to be a no kill nation but I don't think that will be in my lifetime. Spay & neutering programs help, but we need to be more aggressive on puppy mills & backyard breeders.
 
Sue G.
Sue G. (wingett)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I hope this man is right in saying pretty soon the nation will be no kill, the key to that is spaying and neutering. It just sickens me to think of the good animals that are euthanized because of no room. I believe more people are stepping up to help these animals than ever before but it mainly takes more money.
 
Bob C.
Bob C. (rjcronk)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I think the term low kill should be used.. I would imagine our shelter only kills about 5%... usually only very aggressive or sick dogs..
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
YEA!!!! Bob you get it. Folks have to have the mind set of, you can try and save them all, but some can not be.
 
Angel L.
Angel L. (Etain)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
No kill shelters are the way to go but we also need to make sure that the quality of life in these shelters is proper...
 
Sarah B.
Sarah B. (sbutler1976)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree with that. Including foster programs & such would be important. An animal can't spend its live in a cage. I want to read this book first also to see if any of this is covered in it!
 
Amanda R.
Amanda R. (arhoads)
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.