zootoo.com Bringing pet lovers together to help pets and each other

Dogs Snap to Attention for Treats

Browse News

SAN FRANCISCO, Calif. -- Yanking leashes, yelling, and throwing objects -- all tools that trainers can use to get dogs to behave. But a world-renown expert on dog training hopes instead, you’ll use a treat to teach your canine to behave.

Jean Donaldson is the director of the Academy for Dog Trainers. With a puppy in her lap, Donaldson showed how positive reinforcement can teach even the youngest dogs to obey.

“It’s absolutely possible to change animal behavior with punishment. There’s no question that works. But there’s also no question that positive reinforcement works,” Donaldson said. “Would you like to train hurting the dog or without hurting the dog?”

There’s no doubt where Donaldson lands. She’s written several books about the topic including The Culture Clash, and MINE! A Guide to Resource Guarding in Dogs which both won national awards from the Dog Writers Association. Her latest book, FIGHT! A Guide to Dog-Dog Aggression came out a few months ago, in October.

Her six-week academy for dog trainers has attracted participants from around the globe. At a recent session, students each practiced techniques they learned in a classroom-setting with a dog in the San Francisco SPCA which is waiting for adoption.

Without a leash or raised voices, the dogs followed commands such as sitting, heeling, laying-down, walking along side of the trainer, and didn’t eat treats left on the ground next to them until the trainer gave the go-ahead.

Donaldson said in the 1980s, early on the positive reinforcement movement, this style of training received backlash and resistance.

“Dogs are so time intensive and they can be frustrating. People have the urge to take it out on something. It’s no longer legal to take it out on your spouse. It’s no longer legal to take it out on your kids. But, so far it’s still legal to get heavy-handed with dogs,” Donaldson said.

Now, she sees many trainers crossing over to positive reinforcement methods.
Jake Gross from the Nofolk, Va., Animal Care Center said he believes this method can foster “harmonious living between people and dogs.”

“It’s not that using aversive or punishment methods can’t work,” Gross said. “Where I’m from we deal with dogs on chains, dog fighting, things like that."

“Positive reinforcement is by far the way to go to have lasting changes in behavior.”
Donaldson warns against the long-standing methods of yelling, swatting or shaking dogs to correct behavior because of long-term adverse affects.

“(A dog) may learn human hands are sometimes not so good,” she said. “And you can end up with a dog that’s more aggressive because he’s not comfortable with humans, human hands, leashes -- he becomes suspicious.”

The goal of the Academy class is to not just teach trainers, but teach them how to teach pet owners so they can continue to spread the positive word of positive reinforcement.

For more information about Donaldson, the Academy, and positive reinforcement training visit, snipurl.com/sfspca.

Tell us what you think about “Dogs Snap to Attention for Treats” below, and be sure to watch this video at the top right of your page. Share your favorite videos by clicking on the ZootooTV tab. Send us your story ideas by e-mailing us at news@zootoo.com or by calling us at 877-777-4204.



Tags


How do you like this article?

85%, 6 out of 7 users thumbed up.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down

Discuss this topic

Comments



81 comments found.
Show: 50 100 200 Per Page
 
piper33
piper33
1 month ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree with positive reinforcement , who wants to be hit get real , treats are a much easier method .
 
Andie L.
Andie L. (AndieL)
1 month ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Isn't the saying you get more with sugar than vinegar? It's great this has translated to the world of dog training. I know I learn better if I'm given a cookie instead of being yelled at. I'm sure our dogs are no different.
 
Sydney  S.
Sydney S. (yukibaby16)
2 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
This is the best way to train your dog. My mom did this when training her dog and it worked out just fine.
 
ComicKitty
ComicKitty
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I think that positive reinforcement is the best way to train your dog no doubt about it
 
acedogg2001
acedogg2001
3 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Positive reinforcement is definitely the best way to go. Do you like being yelled at when trained for a new job or some other task?
 
Rainie
Rainie (RainieA)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
My understanding in general is that a good owner (alpha) is bossy but not a bully. There is a difference and that is what separates proper corrections from abuse.
 
Carryl D.
Carryl D. (carryld)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree with Betty. We, as people, like positive reinforcement....why wouldn't pets.
 
betty p.
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Positive reinforcement is the best way to train a pet. After all, we humans love it when we are given praise for doing a good job, so why not use that same method with animals.
 
Jennifer S.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
This sounds like a great program. I admit to using a prong collar but try to use it very little, relying instead on treats and praise. It really works!
 
rjlupinskat
rjlupinskat
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Quite interesting. I've heard of the 'clicking' method before, but never knew much about it. It is good to see more animal training being done 'non-violent- when possible, using the idea of bonding with the animal and making it a positive session with them so that they WANT to obey.
 
Pat H.
Pat H. (LuvsDals)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Jean Donaldson know her stuff... positive reinforcement is the way to go. Now if it were just as easy to teach the humans...
 
Stephanie W.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
sounds like a plan to me!
 
Janet V.
Janet V. (janeyv)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Sounds like the only way to go.
 
Michelle E.
Michelle E. (lucyb8)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
My dog is not aggressive until food is involved. In that case, she will snarl and probably bite.
 
ronatha
ronatha
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
You might want to work on that food guarding with a professional trainer as it is dangerous and may even escalate. You never know when you might have a visiter, especially a child, at your home. Perhaps a child has a candy bar dangling in her hand and the dog decides it's his? It is also a problem when you cannot feed your own dog if something happened to you and a friend would have to feed him/her. I know Cesar Milan did great training with a dog with this problem. I do not agree with everything he does but this was on the money.
 
Jason J.
Jason J. (kaige)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
My dog can be the most agressive when he is playing with his tire or rope, but as soon as you tell him to stop he's the biggest mush in canine history!
 
Karen L.
Karen L. (blackbriar)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Lot of treats and positive training/praise methods get lot quicker results than being forceful. The dog will also not likely to become aggressive later in life as well.

When I aquired my Lab/pit mix, I had to find a really good trainer and quick to help me with his behavior problems. The lady I ended up picking was wonderful in helping me train Domingo out of his bad habits, one being VERY aggressive toward ppl and dogs he didn't know. I rescued him from a very abusive home where all he knew was pain and very restricted confinement. The trainer worked with us for months and now he's very proud to be who he is and greets everyone he meets with kisses instead of growls/attempted attacks. What was her main method of training? Treats and tons of it along with praise and play time for being a good boy. She also uses hand signals combined with treats to show the dog what she wants him/her to do. Choke collars and yanking on leashes is forbidden in her classes. Whenever Domingo sees his trainer now, he just HAS to go over and say 'Hi' to her and gets tons of praises from her when he does.
 
dksmommie
dksmommie
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree there is no reason to hit an animal. Treats work for my two.
 
Jessica H.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
i would really like to know how she trains them but i know i probably do not have the money to do that
 
ourstaff
ourstaff
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Dogs are not the only ones who don't respond well to aggressive handing. If you hit me every time you yell "no" the only thing I am going to learn to do is hate you (and maybe to duck). If on the other hand you praise me and give me fattening tidbits....
 
patty
patty (mikkizmom)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
If you hit me I'd be hitting you back!! But unfortunately they can't hit back but they can bite and then they would be taken to the shelter and "labelled" aggressive.
 
patty
patty (mikkizmom)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Training a dog is an ongoing job. Positive reinforcement is what is needed. Yes when they are not "listening" to you (or their trainer) you tend to get a little frustrated but showing agression only begets agression. Patience is needed and a "firm" tone to your voice, not a yell or a scream. And yes treats ALWAYS get attention but as mentioned "gotta watch the weight". Although a good brisk walk or run would probably do both the dog and the owner some good.
As to why anyone would use agression to "teach a dog new tricks" is beyond me!
 
Nancy W.
Nancy W. (Greynanch)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Food motivated dogs respond to positive training via treats quickly and assuredly. There are dogs who are not comfortable taking treats (really!) in stressful situations and most of them will respond to a squeeker or clicker sound or to hands-on and/or verbal praise during training. As Jean D., Karen Prior, Joanne Horton and others with experience and success say, consistency, kindness and understanding your dog are essential to knowing and using the positive method of reinforcement that will work in your training.
 
Patricia  C.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Positive reinforcement is by far the best training tool!
 
criscil
criscil
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I have always believed in positive reinforcement when training my dogs the basics, and have always given them treats when they have been especially good. I do, however, use techniques taught by Cesar Millan (Dog Whisperer) for problem areas. Using methods of each where appropriate has worked well for me.
 
Steph W.
Steph W. (stephwoo)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Recently we brought a new cat into the house. Our old cat was not happy. When they would fight, my husband would yell at our old cat and tell her she knew better. Um...ok!!! I'm sure she understood that!! So I looked it up online and printed info for him to read. Yelling does not help, now we make loud noises instead, like a clap or stomp. Just like raising kids, we need books/online info to help us sometimes!!
 
Jami A.
Jami A. (jamiatwood)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree that positive reinforcement is best in most situations. I regret the times that I have swatted my dog for doing something spastic. She doesn't really learn anything from it, and I just feel badly about it! We went through two sessions of classes, which helped. You just can't cover everything in a controlled environment.
 
Bev P.
Bev P. (bevyrn)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I tried this treat method and found that it works but with so many treats for behaviors during training my poor Mara would vomit each class.
 
maple125
maple125
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I have only used positive reinforcement while training my dogs. It seems to work for me. I have easy to train dogs, also. Some dogs are more stubborn than others and I think each dog and breed needs individual attention, just as children and people respond differently, so do dogs.
 
Talita  B.
Talita B. (Talita1)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I need help with potty training my Yorkie, Maybe then should come help me does any one have any tips I really need them!
 
Eightiesbaby
Eightiesbaby
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
My Dog is pretty good for the most part. When he doesn't listen I don't hit him, but it seems my yelling isn't working.
Maybe I should try this method!
 
ronatha
ronatha
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It is true that sometimes you have to get the dog to refocus on you--they are after all predators and not robots! This is especially true when you have a high drive working/herding dog such as my Malinois. However, I do this by only asking for the behavior once and if she doesn't listen to me I say "eh!" to get her to look at me for guidence. If she still doesn't respond I'll touch her collar and jingle the ID tags (I do NOT pull on it). I ask again for the behavior but I do not treat or praise until I get the proper response or she'll learn to "goof up" to get the reward. I also find plain 'ole good praise is very helpful instead of treats. She learned that she gets to play with a tug toy for a job well done at the military and that works really well for her too. Basically I change it around to keep her interested and that makes it even more fun for her. She does know how to sit or down the moment the word comes out of my mouth, or she sees the hand signal. Dogs use body language in their world and are extremely sensitive to it so it is, in my opinion, the best method if you can use it. Verbal commands are needed if the dog cannot see you to get the command. This is why I've use either, both, or one at a time to keep it second nature.
 
Treats do work wonderfully. My dog will do anything for a peanut butter bone.
 
Carly T.
Carly T. (Carly67)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I totally agree.
 
LINDA421419 B.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I misspelled-DOGS
 
LINDA421419 B.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Treats work well with my dos and also a lot of TLC///
 
Anonymous
Anonymous
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
this comment has been removed from the system
 
tatiana b.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
its really hard to train the dog
 
sharon d.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It's hard to believe that "Actual Trainers"use that method.I can only guess that those people have grown up in dysfunctional families,that yelled and threw objects at them when they were kids,and it's the only way that they know.
Why do people not realize that "A little Sugar,goes a long way?"
This sort of training and behavior is exactly why so many animals get euth,because of their behaviors.Very Sad...
 
Jill
Jill (Kallile)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
People who yell, scream, and throw things to train dogs are not "actual trainers". They teach dogs through fear. Dog's should never be trained when you're angry or upset with them, and lessons should always be ended on a good note where the dog accomplishes something.

A little sugar can go a long way, however I'm a firm believer that the dog needs to see the whole picture. Desired behavior versus undesired behavior. Desired behavior gets praise, undesired behavior gets an attention grabber and a "no". They don't get hit, yanked off their feet, or screamed at. The way good trainers teach 'no' and use other training tools are not "oh, you're such an awful dog. Bad. Bad. Bad."

Promperly used training tools and verbal 'no's simply mean " Stop what you're doing and refocus on me". "No" to Boomer brings his attention back to me--wagging his tail. He looks forward to earning my heart-felt praise, not just another treat.
 
sharon d.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
"Actual Trainers" was said with sarcasm oozing.
As for the little sugar-that was simply a
"It's nice to be nice" comment, That's all.I definitely know there's a "big picture" to consider.
 
Jim  S.
Jim S. (lear08)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Our dog was trained by using treats and the clicker. We have had so much success and have a well behaved (usually) dog.
 
Rainie
Rainie (RainieA)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Since I've only ever had big dogs, I have used treats with limited success, and then they expect it, or they don't do the behavior. I think treats are good for teaching tricks, but if you want your dog to obey basic commands that will save the dog's life, I think treats are not the way to go.

The whole thing about yelling, shaking, yanking, all that isn't done using the Keeler method. We are specifically told not to train once you get frustrated or angry, because then the dog only sees that you are upset, and doesn't know what you want.

 
Esther S.
Esther S. (GarisMom)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
My experience has been that in the *teaching* phase of a behavior, I only reward desired behavior and pretty much ignore incorrect responses. Yelling isn't going to teach a small puppy to sit or down on command, and what is the point of swatting the dog for failure to follow a command it doesn't understand?

However, at some point, I believe corrections ARE essential. Whatever rewards I may be using, whether food or a toy, eventually there comes a moment when the dog is going to weigh the expected reward against doing what it wants to do, such as chase a bunny. Bunny or ball? BUNNY!!

And when that moment comes, the dog must know that obedience is NOT an option. That failure to respond will not just mean "no treat" (forget the treat: BUNNY!), but will result in discomfort -- enough discomfort that BUNNY! isn't worth it.

I would never use a major correction for failure to perform a "fun" exercise (waving, for example), but when I say "DOWN!" the dog needs to DROP WHERE HE STANDS and not keep moving. Three commands are critical for me: down, come, and OUT! (release). These are lifesaving commands, and failure to obey could have drastic consequences. The dog MUST understand that I am not "asking" him to do this; I'm TELLING him. And he has to do it NOW.

It isn't necessary to yell and hit, but a sharp, sort of a "ERF!" or "RARK!" lets Gari know that what he's doing is not acceptable. Behavior shaping and inducive training is wonderful for teaching, but at some point, once the dog KNOWS the behavior, there IS a place for corrections in training.
 
Rainie
Rainie (RainieA)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I totally agree with you. The correction isn't hitting or yelling at your dog, it is usually a more forceful movement to make your dog do the command. For a dog that doesn't sit, you pull up the leash and slightly back so the dog ends up sitting. This is safer for the dog than to try and push down the hips, which can injure the dog's hips. Also, I find that not repeating the command really makes your dog listen the first time. I think those people that end up yelling, hitting or throwing things do so because they are "repeaters". My understanding is that you say it once, and they do it, say it again and again, they tune you out. Correction follows if they didn't do the command you asked the first time. Also I say the dog's name then the command, so as to get the dog's attention. They don't understand the entire English language, so I find saying the name then the command gets their attention well. I have noticed that after a few corrections, I rarely ever need to do corrections with my dogs.

As much as people think dogs are like humans, they are pack animals and need to have a good pack leader. This is the main thing that Cesar Milan preaches, and I find that it is totally true. A dog that respects you as the pack leader, will always listen to you. It is not fear, but simple respect.
 
hsnorthiowa
hsnorthiowa
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
The obedience school training we took our dog to suggested the same thing, and with the treats, I was able to teach my dog things I never thought I would be able to. Once they learn things, they don't have to have the treats every time.
 
ronatha
ronatha
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I have to humbly disagree with the last person. I have learned how to use positive training to even accomplish the distant sit or down stay! Just because you use treats or toys for training doesn't mean you keep using treats all the time--you actually cannot keep them well trained that way. You need to use rewards initially then only occasionally which keeps the dog wondering if they get the goodie now, or maybe if they do it better next time! It's like playing the slot machine which we know can be fun if you win occasionally especially if you don't know when the "win" will happen.If you "win" all the time it becomes boring. You teach the hand signals and verbal command with your reward and eventually it becomes second nature. The great part is your dog really loves to do what you ask!!
 
Jill
Jill (Kallile)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I can't agree with this as a trainer. Will it work? Yes, if you want to carry a treat around all the time. What about when they just have to chase that squirrel across the road and a cars zooming along? Will that treat make them stop and listen to you then when they're in hot pursuit? I doubt it. There are many things that can quickly become more tempting than a treat.

My two dogs are trained using different methods. Reese was treat-trained--Boomer was 'balanced scale' (correction and praise) trained. Reese reaches a point where he becomes bored with food and blows you off completely. Boomer, after just a few months of balanced scale training will stop what he's doing and focus on us at the mention of the word 'no'. He doesn't need "yanked on" all the time, nor do I want him to be. But I know he will be attentive when it counts, and that's what's most important.

 
Tom
Tom (pugbaby)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Positive reinforcement always worked for our dog.Never had to try the other way and wouldn't want to.
 
WickedPineapple
WickedPineapple
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
I agree that positive reinforcement is the way to go... it works on men as well ;)
 
wendy w.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
What can I say....Nothing's stronger than LOVE.......
 
Lynn C.
Lynn C. (MEKOMO)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
"Treats" can be a favorite toy too. I used a tennis ball to help a stray GSD to get over his fears. He just loved the ball and would do anything for me if I would play with him. We bonded so well, that I ended up keeping him.lol
 
terrae01
terrae01
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
This is the way we train our dogs. Love goes a long way!
 
LadyNoah
LadyNoah (LadyNoah)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I don't believe in throwing things, zapping animals with thoe God awful collars, spraying as a way to train. I always use treats, love and pats. A little loven' goes a long way!
 
Cindy M.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
So very true
 
sheri
sheri (moonstardance)
4 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.