Cat Declaw Ban in California -- ZooToo Pet News

slsmile
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

Completely barbaric. Whoever thought of this should be euthanized.

k r. (jkrepp1)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I think is should be banned!! Good for California

cldale729
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 4 users liked it.
Reply

I feel declawing is very wrong! How would you feel if someone ripped your fingers off at the first knuckle? That is just what happens when you declaw a cat.

Leigh V. (allisonkojak)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

I think that declawing a cat is like taking away our fingers. I mean, cats are just as good as humans. We don't take away cats claws, cats don't take away our fingers. End of story.

klw1974
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

GO California!!!! Now the rest of the nation needs to do the same thing!

kjsk74
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

Can anyone actually declaw a cat if they knew exactly what it felt like? Take your last knuckle on any of your fingers...now cut it off!!!! That is what declawing a cat entails....wanna declaw your cat now?!?!?

adinamh
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

No, only bans on mutilation. Which is exactly what declawing is.....mutilation. There is no pain associated with being spayed or neutered, but cut off some tendons and ligaments... THINK ABOUT IT!! Don't base your opinion to defend bad decision you have made in the past. There are other alternatives.

pegasis416
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I feel declawing is a painful approach to dealing with some problems of having a cat. Declawing also limits the animal in defend itself. So i have to aggree with California in making it illegal.

skstc21
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

Whew! I truly have mixed feelings on this one. I used to be 100% against declawing, period. But I was also at home then, and able to supervise my cat and prevent problems with destructive behavior. Now I work in a shelter, and besides the fact that I'm gone all day and can't prevent a lot of destructive behavior, I also see cats surrendered because of destructive behavior. I've had cats declawed and it didn't have any bad effects. I guess my vet was skillful. My cats didn't become biters, avoid the litter pan, or show any signs of discomfort. They're happy and well adjusted. I do think too many people look for a surgical solution instead of attempting good training and supervision. Perhaps the procedure should be taxed in some way to discourage people from resorting to it, with the monies going to shelters to help unwanted cats. People need to understand that many, many people will simply not permit a fully clawed cat in their home. That translates into more cats losing their lives. It's a complicated issue, to be sure.

IamJimmy
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I'm not going weigh in on the whole "is it wrong to declaw" debate, but I do find it silly in California to ban any kind of "elective" surgery on an animal. They should, like most states, make it a nessary thing to spay/neuter your animals, so less animals go into shelters, and it's easier for those shelters to find unwanted animals homes...

Jacey (jjhuntsalot)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

I think it is great to out law this inhumane practice. It is mutilation and the owners either do it out of not understanding or selfishness.

zeus
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 4 users liked it.
Reply

I personally would never get my cats declawed. They never scratch the furniture because I have alot of scratching posts. But I understand why some people dd have it done

summithound
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I have 2 cats, both of which are de-clawed. This was only after I had tried everything else, at least to my knowledge. My cats were destroying my furniture and something had to be done. This was after months and months of trying various things, but to no avail. I would have preferred not to have had to resort to this, but as in my case and I don't feel I stand alone, something had to be done.

marni M. (Marni919)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

It seems to be convinent for cat owners to declaw them but what is not understood look how many of those cats end up outside! Then the cat has no way to protect him/herself. It is unfair to take that away from them!

Cornbread1106
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

get them all

gracieh700
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

great!!!! i htink its rude to declaw a cat. it would be like taking our fingers!!!!!

golfvek43
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 4 users liked it.
Reply

The reason I visit California and not live there....

nicole c. (italianogrl33)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

As a veterinary student, I do not agree with declawing, and I will never practice it when I graduate for my own moral reasons. However, there are many instances where declawing can save a cats life. For example, and elderly person who has trouble clotting wants to adopt a cat from a shelter. The cat would be euthanized if it could not be adopted. The cats are under anesthesia when they are declawed, and it is considered an elective surgery. However, it makes me think of why people neuter male cats when they know the cat is going to stay indoors for its whole life. We do this for our own convenience to prevent spraying, marking, etc. Much like the argument to to declaw cats, it is for our own convenience. Sometimes I feel that there are two sides of every story.

skiser
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 3 users liked it.
Reply

I think a good step would be to inform people what declawing really is. I had my cat done years ago and was never told what all it entailed. Now that I know, I would never have it done. But the fact is that most people just aren't educated as to what it really involves.

Betsy
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 9 users liked it.
Reply

While I personally would never declaw a cat , I do believe that this is a personal choice for the pet owner and it should be left up to the owners. There are people who are diabetic who if they get a bad scratch it could beme a matter of health for them.

Nicole (Nicole42682)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

Exactly! My grandmother was diabetic and she was ALWAYS around my cat. I had to declaw him... she was in love with my cat, so I had to do something! The soft paws didn't work out so well with my cat. Declawing him was a last resort.

jyackley01
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

Declawing a cat is totally inhumane and unnecessary. If declawing is the only way a person will keep a cat in their home, perhaps that person should not have a cat. Would you cut off your child's fingers because they wrecked the living room furniture? Obviously not. There are EASY and humane ways to keep your cat from destroying your furniture. And, if you value your furniture more than your cat, perhaps you should not have a cat.

alexander
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

i want it

alexander
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

thats cool

Danny C. (Ddc2003)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply

Declawing a cat is horrible. The process is not just removing the nail, it is the whole first knuckle! At our shelter, we do not allow it to our adopted pets. This is mulitation. Also, if your cat runs away; it wont be able to protect its self. It could starve to death or be killed by another animal.

jscmom15
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

I think this is so unfair. Who are these people to decide what we can and can't do with our pets. What are the going to say next, we can't cut our childrens hair. You might say those two things are nothing alike...how about circumcision? Will they say we can't have that done to our sons? We live in a free country for a reason. If someone wants to declaw their cat, then that's their choice. Not the states or governments. Declawing is nothing like amputation. If these people would take a little time out of their day and visit a vet clinic to watch a declaw being performed, they would completely chang their mind. I'm for declawing!!

alexander
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

no

Cornbread1106
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

get them all

Mel J. (Xandosa)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I prefer using Soft Paws they are safer and colorful... I bought them at SPCA TampaBay in Largo, FL

kerryb
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I think it's great that they don't allow declawing. I wish they would do that in my state.

Marshamartinis
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

Personally I have 2 cats both of which are indoor cats that are free to roam outside if they choose, I have had neither declawed. I do agree with Jenna however that if you ban declawing, you are going to have a lot of "Adoptive Parents" that will not adopt your cats from your shelter. I chose to leave my cats claws intact due to the fact that they do roam outside & their claws are their means of defense. I know several people however that have only had their cats' front claws removed. I think though if you are going to have a cat that will be inside at all times, you should have the choice to declaw or not declaw. But if it is going to be an outdoor or part-time outdoor I feel the claws should be left intact.... for self defense of the cat....

Grace @ T.C. (sarahlilly1964)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

you know I've seen a lot of cat's declawed and i have never seen one as messed up as the one on the video I'm not even sure it was a real CATS FOOT

jessicaballard
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

Declawing a cat is cruel. It does not solve problems, but only adds to them. Cats use their claws for protection when attacked. If you get your cat declawed, have problems later with them not using the litterbox, and throw them outside, how do you expect them to defend themselves? If you spend time with your cat, you can train them not to claw up your house. My family has always had cats, inside and out, and we have never had to even think of getting a cat declawed!

Hope (thecrazyducky)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I think declawing is inhumane. It`s cruel to the poor cat. How would you like it if someone took you to a doctor and took all your fingernails of? I bet you would hate it, and so would a poor cat. It`s wrong, and it should be against the law.

hcems12
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

i agree with the ban of declawing. i think the state of south carolina should ban declawing.

HYPERMUTT
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

TO EACH HIS OWN

Teresa H. (Houndmom)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 4 users liked it.
Reply

Declawing is barbaric and should be banned every where. I think it will take some time for this to happen, but it's great it's making a start. In the meantime, we need to education everyone on the alternatives and how to trim nails and train a cat to a scratching post. When the ban comes, more people will be prepared for it.

You should watch the surgery if you think it is fine - it's horrible.

alexander
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

i dont think it is wrong

alexander
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

nice ban

CharlieB
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

It should be banned everywhere! Cats have claws for a reason, if you don't want them to do the things they are supposed to do- get a fish.

HCI
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

Sounds painful don't think I would want it done.

b s. (bspringer)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I feel that declawing a cat is just plain wrong. I applaud California for taking such a step in promoting the welfare of cats. If people who declaw their cats would take the time to learn different ways of reprimanding their cat, they wouldn't need to declaw them. I have 3 cats and none are declawed, but don't claw the furniture or scratch anything but their scratching post. Do the people who declaw their cats take into consideration what would happen if that cat should get outside. They would have no protection from dogs or any other hazards. Also put yourself in your cats place. Would you like part of your finger removed just to make it convenient for someone else, so they don't have to train you properly.

kittybratgurl11
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

well it doesn't matter either way but if your cat ever gets lost and has to defend for it's self then it should have it's claws left in but if you no your cat won't ever EVER get out then it's alright i mean i have four cats and there all declawed because they live inside and will never get out

mrsbeckenthal
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I'm thinking that a compromise law could be enacted. How about a mandatory two-week wait for the surgery. The owner could be given some educational information describing training methods which provide options to declawing. At least some of the owners could be convinced that it's not a good idea. The operation usually is done by people who are ignorant of how to teach a cat not to claw, or they are too lazy to deal with the training.

I'm not sure about outlawing it completely. I agree that too many cats need homes, and this will definitely keep some people from adopting. The other thing is that this is the land of free. We can't keep having the government putting limits willy-nilly on our ability to live our lives.

animalcare123
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I think that is everyone choice . I think its the owners choice.

Chelsea (chels24)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply

I think cats should only be declawed if they need to! There are very good reasons why cats get declawed, its not like they get it done for fun!

smile4j9
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

I am not for or against declawing however, I feel if God didn't want them to have them and use them as a means of survival....He would have declawed them Himself.

Linda W. (lillybutt)
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply

Declawing is WRONG!!!! It is like cutting off half your finger. Come on,we are smarter than clawed cat. There are so many ways around this, scratching poles, calming agent, common sense.....When are humans going to take the high road and realize this is a problem we can deal with, without hurting the cat. We can make a difference. Yes it take effort, but it is well worth it.

stanleys2
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply

Personally I do not believe that declawing is a matter of choice. I have had cats that have been declawed (front paws only) and some that have not been declawed. I do hope that the process did not cause pain but I never saw any damage or limitations (other than not being able to shred furniture) to my furry friends. Couldn't this be compared to circumcision choices of a parent on a male newborn? I think people are getting a little carried away and stressing on some silly issues.

alexander
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

i dont think declawing a cat is wrong nither is it right

SCRAPPY
2 years ago

Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply

I FEEL THAT DECLAWING OF CATS, IF DONE AT AN EARLY AGE, SHOULD BE UP TO THE CAT OWNER. OUR COURTS SHOULD NOT MAKE THAT DECISION FOR US AND SHOULD NOT OUR LOCAL GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS. EVERY CAT OWNER SHOULD HAVE THE RIGHT TO DECIDE BASED ON THEIR WANTS AND NEEDS.

Cat Declaw Ban in California

Browse News

Tags

How do you like this article?

Comments

Other news of the day

News Archive

about zootoo

zootoo activities

pets and people

products and services

pet news

get involved