zootoo.com Bringing pet lovers together to help pets and each other

Cat Caught In Custody Battle

Browse News

OREGON – A Portland, Oregon cat is in the middle of a custody battle between its original owner and a couple who paid for the cat's veterinary treatment.

Donnella Whitacre's four year-old cat, Merlin, likes to wander outside. So when a neighboring couple became friendly with the cat, Whitacre agreed to let them see him.

But Whitacre says the couple stole the cat in July – and the white Siamese has been living with them ever since. The couple's lawyer says his clients have spent hundreds on Merlin's vet bills – and even put a lien on the animal. Whitacre says she's not yet seen a receipt for those bills.

Local authorities allegedly told Whitacre to forget about Merlin – that she won't be getting him back. But Whitacre says that's something she can't do – she's been an animal lover her entire life, and Merlin is like a member of the family.

So now she's filed a lawsuit. A hearing is scheduled for November 30th – we'll report back when we get the details.

Tell us what you think under this story. Post your favorite pet videos at the zootooTV tab. Email us your story ideas at news@zootoo.com or call us at 877-777-4204.



Tags


How do you like this article?

46%, 13 out of 28 users thumbed up.
Thumbs Up Thumbs Down

Discuss this topic

Comments



467 comments found.
Show: 50 100 200 Per Page
 
InZeee
InZeee
2 days ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I'll say it's strange but true. I often wonder how many shots and treats and food these stray cats get. There is a lot of people who feed the strays. My cats are all indoor cats so that is first point, don't let you cat out if you don't want someone to steal it. Second point if the other couple who paid the medical bills knew it was her cat why would they of paid the medical bills. I could see if they didn't know the cat had an owner but by the sound of it they knew. Sounds like there is more to this story than what meets the eye.
 
daryl b.
daryl b. (darylob)
4 weeks ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
i once had a cat stolen from my barn and the woman stole her took her home and had her spayed. i searched for her and took her back and the woman wxpected me to pay the bill. i refused telling her she STOLE my cat and i would charge her if she ever came on the property again
 
jennifer m.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
This is confusing! I would never give Simone to a neighbor even temporarily. when I read the title of this article I thought it was about a couple going through a divorce and who gets custody of the animal. Which poses the question . . what happens in cases like that?
 
Carol L.
Carol L. (langsford)
4 weeks ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I would like to know why the original owner did not try to get the cat back sooner. It the other couple did indeed kidnap the cat you would think all the original owner would have to go is file a complaint. I don't know why anyone would spend thousands of dollars on someone else s cat unless the cat were ill or in distress .
The original owner gave up her rights to the cat as far as I am concerned when she did not immediately seek getting the cat back. Confusing a bit to me -
 
Brea
Brea (Brea1)
4 weeks ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I'd like to know how this case turned out. Since pets are considered property, I'm surprised they haven't given the cat back to the original owner. Their wouldn't be a lawsuit if this had been a prized bull or cow.
 
Stephanie W.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
First of all if you really care about the cat you will keep it in the house or atleast know where the whereabouts of the animal are. My dad has a male cat eventhough he wonders around outside he always comes home because he is fixed. If she really care she shouldve fixed her cat and then he wouldnt have wondered off.
 
Patricia  C.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Cats often pick their own families, especially unneutered, unspayed ones. This article didn't say if the cat in question had been fixed. Male unfixed cats wander. I had cats as a child that would wander to my neighbors who had a lot of barn cats and he finally just stayed down there. On the other hand, they had a kitten who came to my house and I took her home at least 3 times. The third time, I told them, if she came back, I was keeping her and she didn't come back anymore. She did want to be my cat, just like Corky wanted to be their cat. Cat choose their owners sometime and there is nothing you can do!
 
Josiesue02
Josiesue02
5 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
First of all, anyone who truly loves their pet and feels it is a member of the family would or should not let it wonder around outside. I feel that if you wouldnt let your children do it then you shouldnt let your animals do it. Second of all, this is why I have a folder for each one of my pets. I keep their adoption papers and all of their vet bills in their folders. I actually did this because when I first moved in with my boyfriend I was worried that if things didnt work out then we would be fighting over the cats and with my folders on each of them, I have proof that I paid their adoption fee and for each and every one of their vet bills (I have my credit card record as well). In a way I must say that I dont think that the original owners will get their cat back and to be quite honest, because of my belief that no animal that is thought of as part of the family should be let loose outside, I really dont think that the owners deserve their cat back.
 
womanintheshoe10
womanintheshoe10
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I agree that cats should not be allowed to wander outside, there are too many dangers and of course illnesses to be caught from other outdoor cats. I wonder how long the neighbors had the cat before the original owner asked for it back. I think the owner should pay the vet bills if she wants her cat back so badly. it sounds like she was willing to let the neighbors care for it and now that it has had it's vet needs taken care of she wants it back.
 
Jamie
Jamie (Sadiesmygirl)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I personally do not believe in letting your cat roam outside, there are to many dangers for them out there. But here are some questions I have about this story...how long was Merlin at the neighbors, why did he have to go to the vets, how much money was spent at the vets?
 
mARY ANN M.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Cats are in danger when allowed to stray outside, and in urban areas they can be hit by vehicles, get into poisons or antifreeze or other dangerous substances in peoples yards or garages, injured by dogs. I say let the couple that took PROPER care of her keep her.
 
Lana S.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Give the cat back to the original owner. IF there are vet bills they should pay them because they had the cat at that time! Then they should go to a shelter and get a cat of their own! These people must have a lot of money!
 
Kim T.
Kim T. (kimboli08)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
there are enough animals for everyone there is no need to fight.
 
Kim
Kim (norswl1)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
what??????? how ridiculous........ aren't there enough cats for everyone?
 
jill l.
jill l. (JillLong)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Just because they love the animal too and were willing to pay for vet care doesn't mean they are now the owners. What are these people thinking? Adopt your own itty.
 
Alex J.
Alex J. (roadisland49)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Why do people fight over animals it is like get your own
 
Doggieluvs
Doggieluvs
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
GET YOUR OWN CAT!!! And quit tying up our courts with leins on cats!
 
Brigit800
Brigit800
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
How do you put a lein on an animal that you are keeping???
 
Sue R.
Sue R. (suerob)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
I'm missing information. Why did the couple steal the cat - did they think it was mistreated? What vet bills? Normal shots & care or was their abuse??
 
suezie
suezie
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 2 users liked it.
Reply
I agree, a lot of missing information.
 
D. Rene
D. Rene (mooredr3)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Strange story...i am not quite sure what i believe.
 
greenkitty44
greenkitty44
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
I hope she wins! That is her cat and they stole her. Stealing is stealing....How could those people think it was honestly okay to just take a cat away from a family?
 
bhilverding
bhilverding
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Can't we all just get along??????????????
 
Ashlee S.
Ashlee S. (ashleerdh)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Why is the cat out wandering the neighborhood anyway????
 
loosey
loosey
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
That's what I was thinking!!
 
Mary G.
Mary G. (Norton)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Ambiguous story. Merlin likes to visit with the neighbors and one fine day does not come home. Mrs. Whitacre MUST suspect where Merlin is, so why didn't she simply go and retrieve her cat immediately? Meanwhile, the neighbors claim to have paid hundreds of dollars in vet bills, but for what services. Was the cat ill? Was it not neutered? or did they just want him thoroughly checked out before they decided to keep him? It seems to me that one cannot unilaterally opt to just take possession of someone elses pet. But in the final analysis I think that Merlin likes the neighbors best. If he didn't, being a cat, he would have found his handsome way home again.
 
Hughie
Hughie
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
If she is an animal lover, why was the cat with the neighbor for so long? Rather than spending money on a lawsuit, why doesn't she just adopt a cat from a shelter and donate the rest of the money she would have paid the lawyers to the shelter to help other animals.
 
Annemarie S.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I don't think all the information was present in the story. If she is allowing her cat to roam the neighborhood, that may be considered property abandonment.
 
Lisa B.
Lisa B. (LBowen)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
There must be more to the story. All the pieces don't fit together so well.
 
Cindy M.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I'd say whomever has receipts for the pets care should continue keeping the cat.
 
Jill6Johnson
Jill6Johnson
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Who is paying the bills? Who is taking care of the cat? so who should have rights to it.......I say the one taking care of it!!
 
Kate H.
Kate H. (dixiepets)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
If the cats been with the neighbors since July why does she want it back now?
 
Cfox929
Cfox929
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
It should be interesting what type decision is made - I hope there is a follow up on this story. I guess the good thing is the cats have 2 families that love them.
 
Natalie
Natalie (Doulton)
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
Another compelling reason for cats to stay indoors. I doubt that the owner is that great if she did not take the cat to the vet. I hope that the other family would have done so for a moggie cat and not merely a white Siamese.
 
Hughie
Hughie
6 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Why didn't the original owners take the cat to the vet when needed and pay the bills. This is a little strange. The neighbor should present the bills to the original owners and if they pay, let them have the cat. It originally did belong to them. There are so many homeless cats in shelters, the neighbor could open her home to an orphaned cat from a shelter and change that cat's life forever.
 
WANSTREET
WANSTREET
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Keep your car inside you so called animal lover. Why did the neighbor have to spend hundreds in vet bills? Was the cat sick and the owner didn't see to its health?
 
Tracy J.
Tracy J. (Tracy2008)
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Another good reason to keep your cat indoors where they are the safest! By letting the neighbors visit with the cat is no reason they should have taken the cat. If they saw the cat needed medical attention, they should have brought it to the attention of the owner and let her decide what to do. If the animal seemed to be mistreated then call animal control. These neighbors just decided to do whatever they wanted!
 
absit
absit
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
i dont see why the other people paid for the vet bills in the first place that is just stupid to do when you know who the owners are
 
Mary T.
Mary T. (matrice)
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I'm glad I don't have to decide this but maybe they should present their bills, get paid and give the cat back
 
wtfginayourehot
wtfginayourehot
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
She should've watched over her cat more. What did she expect, at least another family is taking care of her cat.
 
5doxiemom
5doxiemom
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
She already agreed to let them see him so I don't think she was to attached may be she thought they will take him to the vet and then I'll take him back who knows
 
Linda W.
Linda W. (equs2)
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
What was wrong with the cat that so much vet work needed to be done? Not enough information here to make a decision.
 
Hannanahmom
Hannanahmom
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I say the people who cared enough to pay for the vet treatment should keep the cat. My family took in a dog that had been turned out by our next door neighbor because they didn't want to pay for her heartworm treatment. We did, and had this wonderful dog for 7 years. If you don't want to pay for their care, don't get an animal companion in the first place.
 
8critters
8critters
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Sounds like finder's keepers, I wonder what the vet bills were for, and why authorities don't think she will get him back. Maybe they all see her as less than the pet lover she claims to be. How long did this woman let them "see" the cat that they could take it to the vet and all. Hmmmmm.....I'd be pounding on the door an hour later and wouldn't stop until I got my cat back.
 
Wyoming County S.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
she let the cat outside shame on her
 
Jessica H.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
why would that couple spend money for the cat to go to the vet instead of telling the owner. the couple should just get their own cat or the owner should just get another cat and dont let the couple see it
 
lexina
lexina
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 1 user liked it.
Reply
sounds fishy
 
linda s.
linda s. (furrybabies)
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
just place the cat already
 
joyce01
joyce01
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
Sounds like there's more to this story than meets the eye. Why did the cat need so much attention from a vet? Doesn't sound like she was too good at taking care of her cat!
 
collyn f.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
i agree completely with penny m. this is ridiculous!
 
penny m.
penny m. (pennydq)
7 months ago
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
The fact that local authorities supposedely told her she wasn't getting the cat back, may have something to do with the condition he was in when brought to the vet. "He likes to wander outside" sounds like an excuse to me. I'd go with the people who took him to the vet. She may be an animal lover, but letting the cat wander and being in need of a vet seems like neglect.
 
Kristina  R.
Flag this | Good Point | 0 users voted.
Reply
I don't think we are getting the whole story here. If it is in fact the lady's cat, then why don't they just give her her cat back, and have her pay these so called vet bills.

Other news of the day

Rabbits 'Hoppier' after Mastering Agility Courses

MINNEAPOLIS -- Thumping and hopping ...

News Archive

1,000 Salmonella Infected Turtles Euthanized

PENDLETON, Ore. -– Nearly 1,000 co...

Cat-Eating Festival Sparks Debate

NEW YORK -- An annual celebration in...

Hot Cruisers Kill More K9s Than Stray Bullets

MIAMI -- Two police K9 Unit dogs' li...

Dog Recovers after Losing Tongue to Toy Ball

NEW YORK -- A rubber toy ball has ta...

Few Days Left to Vote for Animal Planet Award

NEW YORK -- The finalists devote the...