My cats barely touched this, and they're usually chowhounds. They're not crazy about anything with liver.

Pros: Hmmm

Cons: not liked

My cats will have a fit if I offer them only FF made of chicken innards! "No thanks, Mom" they'll say, "now give us the fish FF, pul-lease!"

Pros: none really

Cons: the cats avoid this like the plague!

Of all the Fancy Feast flavors I have had the least cleaned plates when I try and get them to eat chick hearts and liver. I know I wouldn't be yumming down a similar flavor so I have to think perhaps my guys are a little too human. :) However, for Daisy (the dog that gets to come through and clean up left overs), this is an extra bonus. somebody always wins.

Pros: Better than other flavors

Cons: Not the favorite of those in charge .....

This food goes down well in our house. There is a large variety of flavours & the price is mid-range. Nutritionally its not the best but not the worst by a long shot either.

Pros: cats eat it all up

Cons: nothing

I have mixed feelings about this particular flavor since my cats INfrequently seem to like it, but virtually hate it other times. Either the flavor itself is inconsistent (sometimes appetizing, other times not) OR my cats just don't know what they want! I'm leaning toward the former explanation since this was also true of an only-cat I had several years ago: sometimes she loved it, other times she turned her nose up. Since the same thing is happening years later with 6 different cats, I think the consistency (or lack thereof) of the flavor is the bigger issue.

Pros: Cats Might Like It For Occasional Variety

Cons: Not one of Fancy Feast's Finest; Questionable Consistency