Shelter dogs enjoy these carvers quite a lot. I might not buy them for Hashbrown as they do contain some crumby fillers but hey are probably really not so bad. I am glad they have been available at the shelter.

Pros: Tasty

Cons: Fillers

My dog really got excited about the smell of these. The only problem I have with them is that they are too small for him to chew pieces off, but too big to be gulped down like a little treat, so he seems a bit unsure what to do with it (my dog is a labrador..) I think they would be great if they adjusted the size.

Pros: All Natural, Smells like real food

Cons: Odd size

We got a bag of these right before Christmas this year and I swear it was like Santa Paws came early. Whenever we got the bag down Dante acted like a puppy. He would literally bounce around the kitchen. Have you ever seen an Akita bounce? It's hilarious! Anyway, he loved them. I just wish they smelled a little better. I wouldn't give them to hm very often because I had to hold my breath when the bag was open.

Pros: Dante seems to love them

Cons: The smell is less than appetizing to humans

We finally bought a bag of the Purina Carvers for our dog and we tried the beef first. She loved it and it was gone in minutes and she was looking for more. Usually she is very picky about her treats and it is rare to find ones she really loves. The main ingredient is beef so its good to see that it is a healthy treat from Purina with no by-products. We will definately be trying the chicken ones.

Pros: Real beef, good for the dog

Cons: not many in the bag, a little pricey but not too bad

My dogs liked them . I had gotten a coupon for a free bag so i figured - no loss if they didn't like them . I now have added them to the list of treats that i buy for my guys!

Pros: Good Size - not to big or too small.

Cons: Not enough in the bag!