I hear these taste great- not that I'm ever going to find out, at least not in this lifetime. Some batches smell a little funny but they are universally admired by any dog I've ever had. They don't smell nearly as bad as some other choices like cow hoofs or bully sticks. It's not just that they're smoked since my dog has declined other smoked products-

Pros: no small fragments left to pick up

Cons: none

my pitt just loves these more than my lab but they both like these

Pros: these are her fav !

Cons: makes a mess on my floor

These things can be a little loud esp if ur little buddy likes them like ours does.

Pros: PAtchy luvs em

Cons: LOUD