I really like this pad. It has made the difference in how my saddle fits my horse. He has a rather high wither and this pad has a large cut out that accomodates this.
The neoprene also is very good shock absorbing and doesn't slip or allow the saddle to slide back- something I've had trouble with before.
I have the 1" thick high wither pad and really like it. It is totally worth the money.

Pros: doesn't slip good shock absorber

Cons: is neoprene

This pad is great. It is just think enough to really help the fitting of my saddle. I like to use thicker pads on my old man and this allows me to get the thickness with you going over board. I love the cuts on the top that allow my horses back to breath, it really helps him not to get to hot.

Pros: comfortable.

Cons: none

This pad really help the saddle fit better. The thick pad help keep it from pinching the shoulders and it's soft and comfortable.

Pros: thick

Cons: none