This product did nothing for my goldfish. I switched it over from regular flakes because he sometimes got air in his stomach and had trouble swimming normally. After 2 days of feeding with this sinking fish food, my fish pretty much stopped swimming all together. It was listless and looked on the verge of death. I can't prove that this was the cause of it's problem, but as soon as I switched back to the flakes and did a bit of tank cleaning, it started swimming again and has been pretty good for the past 2 weeks or so.

Pros: They sink

Cons: They sink too fast for my goldfish

The food is too small for my big goldfish. This also doesn't do much to aid in color enhancement. I do think it's a pretty healthy food and like the fact that it is a sinking pellet.

Pros: sinking food

Cons: too small, doesn't help color

This is great for small goldfish. It is better for them to eat sinking food so they don't gulp air at the surface.

Pros: sinks slowly

Cons: small

I suppose this is stinky because the fish likes it that way so hard to complain about that. I love this food and use it as my primary food for Freckles. The granules are the perfect size for him and I like that they sink. I specifically wanted a sinking food so we could avoid air getting into the fish and causing difficulty for Freckles. He also loves to dig around for any extra crumbs in the gravel. What a little cutie he is! I also find that I do not have a problem with extra slim in my filter with this food as I do with pellets....even sinking pellets!

Pros: Love that it is small and sinks

Cons: Very stinky

This is okay but just another choice in food. Maybe it will work better for someone else but nothing different to me. It is a heathly food so worth a shot

Pros: Has heathly ingredients

Cons: Not much of a difference in color