I've had such good luck with the Purina Pro Plan Selects dog food that I decided on the spur of the moment to try the Pro Plan Biscuits. Boy was that a mistake!

One dog refused to accept one at all but she does tend to be the pickiest so I wasn't too alarmed. The other two accepted them and took them back to their beds. They guarded them with growls for awhile but they weren't eaten. The third time they were offered the dogs wouldn't even come over to get them. I've found them all in the cracks of the doggy bed.

In my house they were a complete failure.

Pros: Nice Packaging - probably safe & healthy

Cons: my dogs don't like them