These treats smell so good I want to eat them!! They smell like fresh apples. My dogs loves them and I feel confident that I'm giving her a healthy snack. The ingredients include rice, oatmeal. apples, molasses, and cinnamon. The few drawbacks include that they are a little expensive, I paid 3.98. They also are great for training medium to small dogs because they're too big and crunchy.

Pros: Tasty, healthy treat

Cons: Expensive

These are great as an occasional treat. I really like this brand as a whole because it seems to be a little more healthier than the others.

Pros: Great taste

Cons: too big for training

This is a great treat to give your dog once a day. Mine eats it quickly and enjoys the taste.

Pros: great taste, healthy

Cons: nope

We just got these and we are VERY happy with them. Our dog loves apples so this really is the perfect treat for him. The size is also perfect for training!

Pros: Affordable

Cons: None

I picked up a bag of the Nutro Natural Choice Crunchy Treats with Real Apple. Oh my goodness, they smell wonderful. You can really smell the apples.

I like that the treats have no corn or corn cluten, no wheat or wheat gluten. It is more of a natural kind of treat which is what I am purchasing more of.

The dogs just love these treats. I think they are too big for training and too hard to really break up. So the dogs get a couple when it is time to kennel up or just as a snack.

Pros: good ingredients, affordable

Cons: too big for training