I buy these instead of greenies b/c they are much cheaper and seem to be the same thing. My dog probably eat them to fast for the cleaning effect to work, but I still try.

Pros: cheaper than greenies, seem to be the same thing

Cons: none

My dogs won't eat greenies, but they love these. My one dog even tried to steal the bag and she would not touch a Greenie. They clean their teeth and freshen their breath.

Pros: cheaper and tasted better than greenies

Cons: n/a

won't be buying them again for them - would buy them for the shelter - so many dogs someone will have to like them

Pros: they are not into these - not sure why

Cons: maybe the taste????

I give my dog a Greenie every night, and when he ran out I ran to Wal-Mart and picked these up. My dog seems to like them, but I am unsure of how well they clean his teeth. I know Greenies work well on teeth because my vet comments on how clean they are and he doesn't have to clean the teeth. If these have positive results on teeth, they are definitely a bargain when compared to the price of Greenies.

Pros: Good Price, my dog seems to like them

Cons: none so far

My dogs go crazy for these things. I give them in moderation and have not had any intestinal issues.

Pros: Dogs go wild

Cons: Price