My golden loves his Nylabone Chubby Buddies hedgehog and his heavy chewing toy destroyer of a sister has yet to destroy it. With up to five dogs playing at a time stuffed animals tend to be destuffed, desqueaked, and dismembered in our household within minutes. This toy lasts and lasts. It has the benefit of a soft exterior with a durable center (instead of stuffing). Being a retriever Jake loves to carry plush toys in his mouth and actually brings this toy out in the yard everyday. Usually, he'll bring it back in, but once in awhile it's left behind to be rained or snowed on. I do wish that the toy was easier to clean, but overall I have been very impressed with the product. The hedgehog is brown and black so it hides all the dirt and slobber longer than light colored plush toys. I will definately buy this product again!

Pros: Most durable plush toy ever!

Cons: Fur isn't easily cleanable.

I adore these, they are so cute and everyone seems to love them, I even bought them as gifts for my friends dogs.

Pros: long lasting

Cons: none

We have the sheep toy for our 3 mini schnauzers and beagle, and they don't really like it too much. I think that the belly is too hard for them and they have a hard time grabbing it. Our dogs prefer squeaky toys with stuffing in the middle. Other than dog preference though, this toy seems extremely durable and I think it would be great for larger breeds that enjoy chewing.

Pros: durable

Cons: not for small dogs

I finally had to replace the dogs' first Chubby Buddy Fish toy after a very long time. These toys are durable and withstood a lot of rough play from my dogs. The hard center core is great for dogs that like to chew their toys because it lasts a long time. These toys do not have squeakers inside. I'm impressed with the durability. The dogs love their Chubby Fish!

Pros: Durable and fun toy

Cons: No squeaker inside---it's a hard toy

Great fun unless your dog likes to shred toys as mine did when they were younger. Excellent for playing fetch in the house. They were somewhat easy for my dog to destroy when she was allowed to chew on it. We've replaced the 2 she destroyed and now limit it to fetch. She loves them.

Pros: great for fetch

Cons: can be shredded like a plush toy