We had a springer spaniel from field lines who was a trained formerly for bird trial competitions. She took her birds seriously. She also took her toys seriously. If it squeaked, she felt compelled to rip it to shreds to find and destroy the squeaker. However, this toy she coveted and loved. She carried it with her everywhere and softly and lovingly chewed on it, never once trying to get the squeaker out. This toy got an A+ from us!!

Pros: Nice design and sounds

Cons: doesn't live forever

I love this toy b/c our golden loves it and it just honks. I am not a big fan of squeak toys so this is a perfect compromise.

Pros: It doesn't squeak

Cons: Like any dog toy it will get a hole in it eventually

Well, our pups loved this one so much that they tore the stuffing right out of it. It was fun while it lasted and we liked the realistic squeaker. Easy to wash - just threw it in the washing machine and it came out as good as new.

Pros: hours of fun

Cons: tore appart pretty easy