One of my dogs doesn't like hard toys so this was for her. She liked it at first, and we would play tug with it. During these tug sessions, pieces would rip off, but not to the point where you couldn't still use it.

I wash it in the washing machine and dryer. It came out super clean, but like fleece, it pilled a bit.

My dogs like to play tug and it seems that it's a display of strength between them. My smaller GSD seems to have issues with hard toys and she doesn't have as strong a bite as my bigger GSD. She likes this toy.

I don't know if it cleaned her teeth since I brush and scrape her teeth as needed.

Pros: Soft on dog's teeth, easy to wash

Cons: Some pieces were ripped off during play

I have one of these for my dog and we also have many of them at the shelter where I volunteer.

My dog likes this fleece rope because she doesn't like large, heavy toys, and it is easy to tug at and carry around. I love that I can wash it and it's good as new, and that it doesn't shed like the threaded ropes.

At the shelter these are great tug toys to take out on walks with mouthy dogs. It gives them something to chew on to keep them from leash biting. We wash and reuse them again and again, and they definitely last longer than plush toys.

Pros: lightweight, washable, inexpensive, colorful

Cons: none

I like these fleece tugs as an alternative to the rope pulls. They seem to last a bit longer with my tough chewers. They also don't make as big of a mess as they unravel. I also found that I could tie them back together in knots after the initial unravel and they couldn't get them apart easily. I've had them for months.

Pros: Not as messy as the rope

Cons: none

We received this as a gift. My dogs enjoyed playing tug-o-war with it.

Pros: Fun

Cons: strength

I hate to say this but my 8 month Cocker had this toy chewed to pieces in about half an hour !

Pros: None

Cons: Easily chewed to pieces