Bought a few fire hose toys, including this one, in hopes that they would hold up to our big chewer. He had a corner ripped off this thing pretty quick. I still throw it for the other dogs, but it doesn't fly very well. Not a bad toy overall, the dogs do seem to like it.

Pros: Tough enough for most dogs

Cons: Doesn't fly very well

My lab loves this toy. Her and my greyhound play tug of war with it everyday. I finally found a material that Bailey can't chew up

Pros: heavy duty

Cons: none