I bought this when 2 of my older dogs started gaining extra weight and kept it on. The food itself was nice and nutritious and had a good array for what could be expected from dry dog food.

I started seeing weight loss about 2 weeks in and then from there the weight loss started fairly quick. I had to mix regular beneful with the healthy weight because while yes my dogs were eating it (Very glad that the dogs enjoyed this brand), they started loosing too much weight.

I was again thrilled that my dogs enjoyed the brand, and also glad they got the the desired weight, but in the end I had to again mix the regular with the healthy weight.

Pros: Did what it was intended to do, was reasonably priced, was not to bad on the ingredients

Cons: Weight loss was a little fast with normal excercise, was hard to mix with water and wetfood