Jerry LOVES these treats and will beg for them! He never really liked treats, most time sniffing them and walking away. But these are awesom - he told me himself! I have to watch how many he gets so we don't have a weight problem.

Pros: The only treat for my cat

Cons: NA

Bullety, Lil Jon & Pants LOVE all treats of this variety (crunchy outside, soft inside). We have tried every flavor of Temptations & they seem to enjoy them all equally. We selected the Savoury Salmon because they offer larger bags of that flavour. I don't think it is a huge savings from two of the smaller bags but the Temptations are the least expensive of the crunchy outside, soft inside treats.
Temptations are so well liked by Bullety that she actually stares at thebag until we are guilted into giving her some. They must have a distinct smell as well because she let theother cats eat the crunchy treats while she waited for the Temptations.
We seem to be more generous with doling out the treats whenthey come out of the big bag though so I am not sure we will continue to getthe big bag.

Pros: Our cats love them

Cons: The bigger bag doesn't last longer because we are more generous

Kitties love them. They have crispy surface, then soft inside. Of course fishy smell, but at which draws the cat to them.

Pros: Great

Cons: none

My cats love these! I use them to train my cats to stay off of the sofa.

Pros: They are good for them and they like them.

Cons: They are harder to clean.

These are very popular kitty treats in my house, and better revceived than the Goodlife recipes. I have tried a variety by the same makes, but none really have the universal appeal of the Savoury Salmon. My dieting cat can enjoy them, as well, since they are only 2 calories each (he is quite of salmon, so that is important). The non-fishy kitties like them, as well (no idea why, but I go with it).

Great stuff!

Pros: 2 calories each

Cons: none