The treats are nummy to my cats, but as for tartar control I don't buy it.
They scarf them down so fast how could they have enough time to create the friction needed to reduce tartar?

Pros: Cats love them

Cons: None

I buy them because the cats love them and I have some probably false hope that in some way they are helping their teeth. I'm with that other comment about the tartar thing being a marketing ploy. Still, I must say that it is effective (the marketing I mean).

Pros: cats love 'em, no mess

Cons: not sure they affect tartar at all

Jasmine is a very picky eater and usually will not eat treats. These sounded tasty so I thought I would try them. She sniffed them but was not very interested. I know other people with cats who say their cats love these so I am not sure that Jasmine is a very good critic as far as these treats go.

Pros: Yummy treat

Cons: None

OUR CAT KATIE LOVED THIS TREAT. I HOPE THEY WERE GOOD FOR HER TEETH.

Pros: A GREAT TREAT WITH TARTER CONTROL

Cons: DON'T KNOW OF ANY

My cats love these treats Would eat the whole pkg if I let them. I have one cat that is 9 and his teeth look good so I think the tarter control must help.

Pros: Cats love

Cons: none