When my cats were younger they played with this toy all the time but now that they are older they don't give it a second thought.

Pros: Young cats or kittens love it

Cons: Older cats don't care

My cats initially enjoyed playing with this toy. Now the only time it gets any use is by new cats added to the family. My cats prefer the turboscratcher maybe cause it doesn't slide around as much.

Pros: Entertaining for new cats

Cons: Slides around too much

The Crazy circle is just one thing you need to make your cats truly insane. I learned that a looong time ago!

Pros: My cats play with this all the time

Cons: na

The cats do enjoy crazy circle - mine doesn't have the light - that might be interesting to try this one - however, turboscratcher beats this for this type of toy.

Pros: they like it

Cons: none

My four cats have played for HOURS with this toy. It is versatile--sometimes I put their stuffed mice toys inside which they really like to grab with their claws. It's also a toy where all four cats can get involved...kind of like sitting around the campfire singing!

Pros: Durable, all ages, inexpensive

Cons: None