I don't know why but my girls much prefer the carrot over the other toys like the banana or cigar.

Go figure.

Pros: They love it

Cons: Nothing

My cats love this toy. It was a big hit. Unfortunately, one of the dogs packed it outside and lost it.

Pros: has catnip

Cons: feather was destroyed

Despite the catnip fill interior and the feather on top (my cat loves birds) this does not hold my cat's interest for long. I, however, like the fact that the catnip can be removed and replaced, so have the option of filling it with dry catnip or fresh catnip leaves.

The plush carrot body is nose nuzzling, but I think my cat may be intimidated(?) by the large size.

Overall, it's a safe toy that combines the senses for a few moments of kitty stimulation.

Pros: Refillable

Cons: Not a big attention grabber

My cat loved this carrot so much, he destroyed it. This was pure fun for him, he carried it everywhere. He did tear the feathers off and managed to get the catnip out of it. I will look for another one, for sure.

Pros: he loved it

Cons: none

my cat absolutely loooves this toy. He carries it around in his mouth and likes you to throw it so he can play fetch. My cat loves the feathers. The toy doesn't make noise and there's not chance your cat can choke on the toy so it's nice to know your cat can play with this toy when you're not at home without worrying.

Pros: My cat's favorite toy

Cons: You'll find feathers all over the house