Nutro Natural Choice Complete Care Weight Management Indoor Cat Food

This has less fat and if your cat is used to eating fatty food they may turn up their nose at this, bear with it, the best thing you can do is get the weight off of your overweight cat.

Pros: Works

Cons: Cats will take awhile to adjust to this

Both Teeny and Mr. Bud like this food. I fed it years ago, before I started reading about what's in pet food, and how less grain filler is better for your pet. We switched around and tried all sorts of premium kitty foods, but Mr. Bud has a sensitive stomach that didn't get along very well with most of them.
Recently I went back to Natural Choice weight management, and I have noticed a distinct decrease in litter box odor. Both kitties eat this food readily. Mr. Bud's dry skin seems to have gotten a tad worse since we've gone back to Natural Choice, but that may be because it's getting cooler and we've had the heat on. I've also not noticed any decrease in weight, but neither have I noticed any gain.

All in all, I would definitely recommend this product.

Pros: Mr. Bud's tummy likes it

Cons: Has more animal byproducts and grain than I'd prefer