When one of my cats had a weight problem I tried this food. And it worked! I was afraid she would hate it, but it must taste ok because I kept her on it for many years.

Pros: Really Helps an overweight cat

Cons: none

i tried a bag of this and the kitties woofed it right down. Not sure that it had any real effect though.

Pros: they like it

Cons: i'm not sure they lost any weight

My diabetic cat has done great with this product. We have his weight down and is now off of insulin.

Pros: Great weight control

Cons: Price

Over all, not a bad food for kitty. Mine really haven't lost much weight on the weight control but it's what the vet told me to feed them so we're giving it a try. I wish they had smaller food sizes as my smallest female seems to have a hard time eating this food.

It smells decent enough and doesn't make their poo smell nasty like some other brands do.

Pros: wide variety of choices for different lifestyles

Cons: seems a little on the "blah" side for kitty, makes for upset tummy sometimes

My cats love this food. So much that I have to watch them because they like to cabbage the other cat's bowls. When they hear the lid pop on the container.. they know that a tasty treat awaits them. My Arthur is still a pudge but I think that he partakes in my skinny kitty's portion. She looks great... and he looks full.

Pros: It limits the calorie intake of my fat cat.

Cons: My cat is still fat.