My cats love this food. Even I think it smells good!

Pros: Premium ingredients, even smells good

Cons: None

My sister's 2 cats will ONLY eat Merrick's Grammy's Pot Pie. They turn their noses up at any other food. Must be something about the taste.. =)

Pros: all natural ingredients, no by-products

Cons: a little more expensive

A pet supply store employee once told me about a trick he and others played on a new employee.... they poured Grammy's Pot Pie into a pie crust, heated it, and told him they had an extra chicken pot pie in the lunch room. He gobbled it up and never knew the difference. My cats like it, too.

Pros: high quality, healthy, little additives, tasty,

Cons: your friends will think it's human food and eat it and you won't have any left for the kitties

My older cat, loves this food! He'll eat it SO fast! He enjoys the flavors of almost ALL Merrick canned cat foods, and meows excessively when I bring it out. He shows no sign of indigesten, or stomach problems.

Pros: Love the Name, Great food!

Cons: None

My little girl doesn't always like wet food, but she loves this stuff. Its a special treat for her when she's been good or on holidays.

Pros: Great Tasting

Cons: Price