11:14pm
Pros & Cons: Big or Little Dogs?
104 comments
A lot of us are dog lovers...but some have a size preference. What do you think is the pros or cons of having a big or small dog? How about a medium dog? Which do you prefer (or not) and why (or why not)? I, in particular, LOVE small, medium, & large, but would rather have the small ones....your thoughts, please.
1 week ago
1 month ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
Growing up, we always had Feists, Chi's,..... etc. I think that the smaller dogs are just what I'm used to.
2 months ago
When I was 8 and told I had asthma we got a Chihuhahua (sp?) for me, her name was Cricket. She was my heart and soul and best friend for many years. Her and my grandmother's (whom we all moved in with to take care of in her old age) German Shepherd Missy became QUICK friends, inseperable actually. I grew up with these 2 by my side. When Cricket died, Missy wasn't too far behind, old age caught up with them. Soon my Mom brought home a Shih Tzu named Gizmo. Gizmo was my shadow from 1990 - 2004. I never loved a dog more than I loved him. When he passed away, there was a huge hole in my heart... in my life. I swore I could never love another dog the way I loved Gizmo.
I have always loved cats however. But that's another story.
When it comes right down to it, I prefer a smaller dog because I am a small person (petite and only standing 5 foot tall). Big dogs intimidate me. However, my husband wouldn't get a small dog this time around. When I had to make the choice, I knew that I had to pick a smart dog breed that wasn't small. I grew up around German Shepherds (my family breed and raised them all my life) so I knew how smart the breed is... and how loyal. I told my husband it was a GSD or nothing. That's how Re-L came into my life.
I love my GSD but I still prefer my kitties. All my animals are SPOILED rotten... I do miss having a small dog and sometimes contemplate getting a pug... it might happen.
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
Sounds like your baby is very lucky to have you.
2 months ago
Sounds like your baby is very lucky to have you.
2 months ago
I also like the fact that when you have a large dog, most folks take notice and I feel more protected especially when I have my pit bull mixes with me. They are smaller than my labs, but the looks is enough even if they are sweet.
I also like something large to cuddle with when husband is not home. I like knowing that I will not be able to roll over and smash a small dog. There is no moving the big kids when they are in the bed with mom.
The cons to having a large dog is if it gets injured. There would be no way of picking up Hrothgar or Aegir and getting them into a car. It would take two of us. Also large dogs eat more, have more waste and can counter surf easier.
However, I would still have my large dogs over a small dog. The small ones are cute, but not for me.
2 months ago
However, I do have a recommendation. As we get older, it's more difficult to take care of a strong or aging pet. If you're a senior, you might want to consider adopting a smaller dog that you can comfortably carry. As stairs become more difficult for you, they will also become more difficult for your pet and may require your carrying them up and down.
In addition, my own mother was injured when her medium sized dog spotted a cat and pulled her down the steps. My mother now has a permanent dent in her leg because the muscle was cut when she landed against the concrete edge of her garden's wall. It all happened in a split second.
These are just things to think about.
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
I have three cats, and even though they aren't as affectionate as dogs, they are already underfoot enough. I couldn't imagine trying to do something with a little dogs jumping around, trying to get my attention, and all that jazz.
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
With that said, I have always preferred big dogs as they are often easier to housebreak and you can enjoy a bigger lap warmer as well as an athletic buddie and protector. It is a personal choice and lifestyle must be a consideration!
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
Extra Large breeds I'd consider getting would be in no particular order:
Bernese Mountain Dog
Greater Swiss Mountain Dog
Great Dane (named Scooby of course)
Great Pyrenees
Mastiff (all different types)
Saint Bernard
Newfoundland
German Shepherd
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
Others may have a lifelong preference for a particular size or breed of dog, just as some prefer long- or short-haired dogs.
My personal preference was always the big northern breeds: Siberian huskies and Alaskan Malamutes. They are gorgeous dogs and enjoy activities like taking walks, going for runs, pulling things (whether sleds, someone on skiis, etc.). They also tend to like to "go for a run" -- with you or without you, which means you're constantly alert for them to dart through an open door.
However, almost ten years ago I had a 'polar shift' in my thinking: Wiggles Blue Heeler came into my life. He's half the size of the bigger dogs (though some folks think a 45- to 50-pound dog is "big"), but what he lacks in size, he more than makes up for in Loyalty, with a capital "L." Loyalty and love are the hallmarks of this fellow.
It wasn't his size that attracted me -- in fact, I actually thought of him as a big small, considering my several previous dogs -- but I'm really not drawn toward small breeds (short- or long-haired), though I've never thought about why.
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
I loved the Siberian Huskies and I still do. They were such fun dogs. These particular dogs had been sled dogs and they acted like sled dogs. These dogs had been placed in rescue because the leader of the pack had died and the pack wouldn't follow a new lead dog. I would call the leader dogs name and all the dog would begin to howl to let me know where they were. I thought that was really fun when I was really young and I called out for the leader at least once a day. The dogs had been trained to howl when the lead dogs name was called. I still remember the special way they howled.
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
You also make a good point about a person's comfort level in managing a dog, big or small....not everyone's geared up for handling a large dog, nor a small dog....and THANK GOODNESS FOR THAT!!!! That way all dogs of all sizes can have a place in this world with a family....
2 months ago
2 months ago
Oh, and hey, I didn't KNOW you were a Celt, too!?! That's cool!!!
2 months ago
2 months ago
Uh oh, jsut realized I commented on the wrong one! OOPS! LOL
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
I love all dogs.Big or small they are all unique,and wonderful!All of my dogs have their own personalities and quirks,too.Some will sneak food or toys, some won't.Some keep to the rules like the gospel, and some will test them every so often!Here are just a few of my experiences with them!
BIG DOG PROS- are good,fun exercise,most like to play vigorously,enjoy hiking and can keep up,amazingly kids always finish their dinner with them around,like to cuddle and add extra warmth during cold spells,always on best behavior for a treat or car ride,like to nap with you,give a sense of security out on walks,bark when doorbell rings,can scare off people,bring the newspaper :),dig great holes for plants!
CONS-bed hogs,can scare people away with size,prefers toilet bowl over water bowl,gets toilet seat wet after drinking from it,eat a ton,bigger land mines,hard to relocate because yard size is an issue,can break and knock things over with bionic,wagging tails,can dig up plants and create a crater in 10 minutes or less!
LITTLE DOG PROS- can almost take anywhere,cannot drink from toilet or knock over trash,cuddle nicely,always enough room on bed,chair or sofa,mysteriously hold power and govern over other dogs and cats:),eat less,make smaller poo,make cute nests for themselves in blankets and laundry baskets,accessories are cheaper,can live comfortably in smaller home or yard,easier to handle,bark to let you know someone is outside,the mail has been delivered,crickets are chirping,or that trees are making shade!
CONS- farts are as noxious as the big dogs,can become an irrational,territorial,ego-maniac dictator over house,toys,people or sofa,go on search and destroy missions for lost socks and panties,bury treats in sofa and laundy baskets,and they disrespect the table rule when they think you are not at home to see it,some steal toys and food -in the slyest of ways-from sweet,unsuspecting children!
2 months ago
This dog's tooooo big!
This dog's tooooo small!
This Medium Dog is Just Right!!!!
LOL! Wiggles Blue Heeler LOVES to be picked up and carried (actually, "carried" is more like "rocked" in my arms, and he loves it when I play music and rock him!), but I've always had a "strong back and weak mind," so his almost fifty pounds is effortless!
All those years of having horses, I've picked up two bales of hay, two full five-gallon buckets, two of things, even though they were twice as heavy, because it's easier to carry things one in each hand and be balanced. I've staggered a bit with two nice, heavy bales of alfalfa hay, but it CAN be done!!!
Have carried a 90-pound Husky a couple of times, but not very far!!!
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
Well, in Kelsie's aunt Sandy's crew, the only girl she has bosses everyone...funny sometimes which ones run the pack, huh?
2 months ago
So thru necessity and an excellent example of small dogdom, small dogs are my "favorite" now... or at least the size I can live with.
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago
2 months ago